• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

why no 'Star Trek vs Aliens' comic series?

If you want an example of what a "Star Trek does Aliens" story would be like, Alien: Covenant is that. I went to see it yesterday, and it kept nagging at me how much the story played by Star Trek rules -- and, for that matter, how much parts of it felt like "The Cage." There's a human distress signal from a planet that shouldn't be possible, a landing party, a healthy dose of "strange new worlds," and a very literal exploration of the hoary "what does it mean to be human" chestnut. Covenant plays out like the absolute worst case Star Trek scenario, and the wonder to me as I left the theater was why things like that don't happen to Starfleet crews more often.
I suspect that has a lot to do with the involvement of John Logan as a screenwriter...without spoiling anything, I could definitely see parallels to the plot of Star Trek: Nemesis as I was watching Covenant.
 
Star Trek did have a story that came close to a Trek vs Alien scenario. That story was in the episode (TNG) "Genesis". Picard was hunted by Trek's version of a xenomorph, the monster Worf.
 
They decided Aliens wasn't enough are planning to crossover the whole nine yards, right?
250px-AvPvtT.jpg
Just missing Robocop.
They did do a Robocop vs Terminator.
Star Trek did have a story that came close to a Trek vs Alien scenario. That story was in the episode (TNG) "Genesis". Picard was hunted by Trek's version of a xenomorph, the monster Worf.

Janeway was definitely channeling Ripley in Macrocosm, too.

Don't forget that Tatan'atar did fight a Xenomorph in one of the DS9R books. I've often wondered if that means Xenomorphs do exist in the Trek universe, or if he stumbled across one of the Alien movies somewhere in a database and thought the it looked like a worthy adversary.
 
Don't forget that Tatan'atar did fight a Xenomorph in one of the DS9R books. I've often wondered if that means Xenomorphs do exist in the Trek universe, or if he stumbled across one of the Alien movies somewhere in a database and thought the it looked like a worthy adversary.
Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait... When did that happen?
Edit: Cathedral in the holodeck?
 
Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait... When did that happen?
Edit: Cathedral in the holodeck?
That might be it, I just remember that he was fighting a bunch of aliens on the holodeck and one of them was apparently a Xenomorph. It was fairly vague, and I honestly didn't even pick up on it until someone mentioned it on here, after I'd already read it.
 
That might be it, I just remember that he was fighting a bunch of aliens on the holodeck and one of them was apparently a Xenomorph. It was fairly vague, and I honestly didn't even pick up on it until someone mentioned it on here, after I'd already read it.

Me neither. I was never a big fan of the Alien franchise; I've seen the first four movies, but mostly not for a long time, and so the connection never occurred to me.
 
a video charting what happened to TNG v Aliens: Acceptable Losses
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
a video charting what happened to TNG v Aliens: Acceptable Losses
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
That’s a complete waste of time. He has one piece of art from the cancelled comic, and absolutely NO information about why it was canned.

Don’t give this guy clicks.
 
That’s a complete waste of time. He has one piece of art from the cancelled comic, and absolutely NO information about why it was canned.

Unless someone, such as the Tiptons, talks about the cancellation, I doubt we'll ever know. My assumption has always been that one studio or the other had second thoughts and the plug was quietly pulled.
 
It just occurred to me, when I saw this thread active once again, that Louis Armstrong's rather well-known quote (when he was asked to define "swing") is the perfect answer to the question posed by the title:
"If you have to ask, you'll never know."

Nearly six years ago, . . .
Good point, although, to be fair, in "Operation--Annihilate!" nobody seemed too concerned with defending the neural parasites' right to exist!
Neural parasites? That's Blastoneuron portalanum carabastosii to you!
 
Last edited:
The Xenomorph with the human skull carapace is creepy as fuck.

I was thinking about this project over the weekend with the announcement that Dark Horse's Randy Stradley is retiring.
 
Unless someone, such as the Tiptons, talks about the cancellation, I doubt we'll ever know. My assumption has always been that one studio or the other had second thoughts and the plug was quietly pulled.
At the time Alien Covenant was just about to come out and Ridley Scott didn't want anything to distract from the films (especially with another sci-fi franchise involved). I always had hoped they just delayed it but it seems pretty dead.
 
J.K. Woodward has posted some of his completed artwork for the cancelled TNG/Aliens crossover on social media. It's the same art posted above (I should have looked backwards), but he does add this: "It never got past a 12 page script for FCBD and 4 covers, but I really wish we could have followed through."
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top