Many have previously stated in this thread that men cannot truly understand the female experience. That may be true. But then, by the same token, women can't understand the male experience.
Society's narrative is basically the male experience. The male experience also isn't generally full of being objectified, abused, harassed and stripped of agency.
So how about we focus on the actual problem?
Men being told that they can't harass a woman even if they're feeling attracted to her, isn't really something I feel much sympathy with.
And doesn't that drive you mad?
The fact that asshole women have boyfriends, too?
What the hell? Of course not. Why would I care?
I suppose that means it does drive you mad that men you consider to be not as nice as yourself, have girlfriends.
Again: "Being nice" doesn't entitle anybody to any romantic feelings. There is a lot more to romance. And it's pretty patronizing to think that you know better what these women really want than they themselves do.
If you're seeing an abusive relationship you can of course offer help. But even if her current relationship is awful, that doesn't mean that she should really be having romantic feeling for you instead, just because you're nicer. Maybe she just isn't attracted to you.
And while context does matter, how is a stranger supposed to know what your specific boundaries are? Like I said, perhaps he's merely treating you the way that he wishes you would treat him? Have you ever tried?
You're pretending this is way more difficult than it really is. It's not rocket science, really.
A woman who is alone in a club? Sure, approach her and ask her if she's interested. If she isn't, tough luck. You're not entitled to anything just because you think she's hot.
That is very different from catcalling a random woman on the street who is just going about her business. That's never okay.
And don't even get me started on what guys seem to think is acceptable at the workplace.
I'm not sure why this is such a difficult concept. Respect women's agency and don't treat us like objects. We're human beings, too.
The problem is that you assume that every man who is interested in sex or asking for sex believes that he is entitled to sex.
I don't assume that at all. There are men who take rejection perfectly well and continue to be polite. Many men sadly do not. They are the problem.
You know, the men who call you an uppity bitch just because you politely rejected them. Or the men who think "No" just means they need to try harder instead of respecting my agency.
Just because you feel threatened, it doesn't always mean that a threat is there. Sometimes it does. But, statistically, you're no more likely to be victimized by a violent crime than anyone else, male or female.
That is dismissive nonsense and you know that. Do you ever have to worry about getting raped when you're out alone at night? Or heck, even during the day, when a random man decides to follow you around for 15 minutes to look at your legs or whatever. Yes, these things regularly happen to women.
The fact that we always have that in the back of our minds is not paranoia. It's part of our everyday experiences.
Have you seen the statistics? Do you know how incredibly likely it is for a woman to get raped? When 1 in 4 women gets raped in college?
If people's chances of being murdered were even remotely the same, nobody would even leave the house anymore.
Oh, damn... but even that doesn't help because many women are raped in their own houses by friends and family.
Do you understand how incredibly arrogant and tone-deaf it is for a man to tell a woman not to worry too much about this shit?
What I'm saying is that none of us have full control over our outside environment. We can try to protect ourselves as much as we can but other people are unpredictable by nature. We are all at times subject to treatment from other people that we don't like. You try to rationalize it by saying that it happens because you're a woman and society doesn't respect women. In reality, most stuff happens simply because you were there and the other person has complex issues of their own.
That is nonsense.
First of all these things do happen because we are women and rape culture and sexist society do reinforce this behavior.
Men are not facing sexual harassment, abuse and rape like that.
And then: Wow, good job being dismissive. "It happens to everybody" and essentially "Men will be men" are absurd things to reply to serious concerns about a society that actually reinforces this behavior through a sexist narrative of objectification and male entitlement.
But perhaps this theoretical man is seeking for himself some kind of outside sexual validation from a woman that he sees and finds attractive? How would you suggest that he obtain it?
By treating us like human beings.
But none of what you're talking about actually has anything to do with sex. That's my point. In our society, a man can't just be sexy of his own accord.
Of course they can. What world do you live in?
Attraction is obviously not limited to physical attraction but there are many ways for men to be physically attractive. It's true that society expects it of you less than it does of us (which seems to be changing slowly).
Women can wear make-up & stockings & high heels & corsets & all manner of things that serve no purpose except to make her sexier.
For male gaze?
I can't stress enough that I primarily pick my clothes based on the styles I personally like, my own sense of aesthetics, beauty and design and how wearing them makes me feel.
Whether or not that looks sexy to some random guy is pretty damn low on my list of priorities.
Fashion is a way to express myself.
Sure, it's nice when that makes
me feel confident, stylish and sexy.
She can take steps to sexually objectify herself if she chooses. What recourse is there for heterosexual men who want to be sexually objectified?
Objectification is horrible. It's awful and dehumanizing. Even if it sounds interesting to you because of some kink, it really loses its appeal when you're faced with it almost every day of your life.
As I said, just because someone is requesting something, it doesn't automatically mean that the asker feels entitled to it.
We are not talking about guys who politely approach us in some club or bar and then take rejection well. I always try and be super-friendly and polite then. I just expect to be treated like a human being. And decent men seem to have no problem understanding that you can approach a woman in a club because you're attracted by her, and still treat her like a human being and respect her agency. These men are not the problem. In fact I very much enjoy flirting with men who treat me like a human being.
We are talking about men who objectify us, feel entitled to our attention, our bodies and possibly more.
But if we're going to be talking about gender relations, one of the questions we need to ask is: Why does this seem to be happening only one way? Why are men interested in sex with strangers while women are not?
Apart from the fact that the statement is nonsense (You make a lot of weird assumptions about female desire), it really isn't a question we desperately need to ask.
- Some men are engaging in catcalling.
- Presumably, they are doing this because they want to have sex with the women that they are catcalling towards.
I think there's way more to it. The power trip they feel when they can use their position of dominance in society to objectify a woman in wildly inappropriate contexts. The entitlement they feel that tells them that their male opinion on women's bodies is so important that they need to let everybody know about it. And lots more.
So what would that tactic be? Perhaps women would have some insight as to what they do find sexually appealing?
I can only speak for myself but: Men who treat me like a human being with agency, who are open-minded, my kind of funny, intelligent, who love long conversations (true conversations, not just listening to their own voice) and who
fascinate me. And yes, if we're just talking about sexual appeal physical attraction plays a role, too. Obviously.
There are many other qualities like being loving and caring, not being afraid of your emotions...
Oh hell, and they need to be nice. Shocking.
It sounds like a lot but it really isn't. I think most people's list looks pretty much the same. We are attracted to people who fascinate us.
In answer to your bank robber analogy, the answer is to get a job. Getting money is not, in theory, a difficult question. Getting sex is much more complex.
So that's your excuse?
Bank robbery is a crime, so is rape.
You're saying there are ways to make money other than bank robbery so bank robbery is bad.
You're also saying getting sex is more complex. Now first of all I think that's bullshit. Economic success isn't easy. We probably have more poor or almost-poor people in society than we have eternal singles.
But back to what your statement implied: There are hardly any ways to get sex so it's okay to ignore a woman's agency?
No, hold on a second there: Have you really processed what a scary statement that is?
I know I felt sick when reading your post and it seems I wasn't the only one.
{Emilia} herself said previously in the thread that sometimes a woman might want to be objectified in the course of some sexual role play or something.
That's the point. Role-play involves agency. Wanting it and communicating that.
I don't know how many times we have to explain agency here.
Sexually objectifying somebody who does not want that is something completely different.
I never said I wanted it. But I can imagine situations where a man would wish to be sexually desired with the kind of vigor with which men often have for women.
You're underestimating female desire. I almost giggled when I read that.
We love sex. We just don't force it on others when they reject us. If that is the "vigor" you meant.
But because this doesn't tend to happen
Intense female desire and lust? Of course it does.
And yet, it seems that only men are engaging in catcalling. I'm just trying to get to the bottom of that.
It's not that hard. It's a symptom of a systemically sexist society of male entitlement and female objectification.
But then, there's this unfortunate notion in our society that sex is something that women aren't interested in and that it's something that men have to "trick" women into doing or something. Asking for sex, although often done in a very vulgar fashion, is treated as an unwanted intrusion even in concept. Women ask to be respected and yet treat the sexual desires of men with contempt.
There is so much wrong in these few sentences, it's amazing.
We do not treat men's sexual desires with contempt at all. What we do treat with contempt is when men try to force these desires on us by objectifying and harassing us.