• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Season 3

I liked the guy who played "J'onn" in Star Trek V as Morgan Earp.

Rex Holman did a great job. Two totally different characters. Makes you wonder about his other acting roles.

I mean, the entire Earp gang was well played.
 
I think Mr. Spock might have wanted to Ponfarr Droxine...

Yes but why?

I know she's amazingly hot but is that what Spock's about?

Does he want a shallow princess? And then he goes blabbing to her about sex. I just hope he was trying to get rid of her;)
 
I was thinking the same thing at the beginning of Season 2, with some of the episodes taking a sudden departure from tone in the last minute and everyone making silly comments and forced laughter/smiles.

---

So I just finished Turnabout Intruder.

The Savage Curtain was fun. Seeing Lincoln in space has unfairly portrayed this episode as silly, but when you watch it, it's great.

The actor who portrayed Lincoln did a great job. At first, I was apprehensive when I saw Abe Lincoln in space, but as the episode goes on and we get to spend a little time with Abe, I found myself being won over. I liked Abe. And I felt bad when he got a spear in the back. I also liked Surak a lot.

All Our Yesterdays. Here's another example of Season 3 witch-hunting. Spock eating meat. Going into the episode, I was thinking Spock was just eating meat to eat meat and that the writers had forgotten about the character's vegan status. But in watching the episode, it's quite clear that Spock isn't feeling, acting or behaving normally. There's a reason for it and it's because the time travel has altered his personality. It's NOT like That Which Survives, and Spock acts abnormally for no reason.

No, the only indication of violating characterizations I found in the entire series was in "That Which Survives" and slightly in Cloudminders when Spock is discussing Pon Farr.

Turnabout Intruder, similarly, gets witch hunted for being sexist. I think that's rather extreme. Why is it sexist? Did I miss something? Janice Lester is a MURDERER *and* a maniac, so of course she doesn't get to be a starship captain. HELLO!

Anyway, Season 3 had its fair share of great stories, character growth and humanism that we came to love in Seasons 1 and 2.

The only problem was the budget, since it's obvious they had to go claustrophobic keeping everything on minimal sets, or the Enterprise sets.

Am I wrong or was The Paradise Syndrome the only episode in Season 3 with location shooting?

What a show. My favorite show of all time. What if they found out about demographics before cancellation? What if they were given that Monday night at 8 timeslot?

If only, if only...

And on to The Animated Series...

I've enjoyed all of your feedback and agree with almost all of your points and observations. For me, 'Spectre of the Gun' ranks in my all-time top ten episodes. For that one, they made a masterpiece where there was no money. It's an episode that makes you think. There are several other S3 episodes that are among my favorites. I can only wish they had kept making TOS.....even if it had been at the S3 standard.

I also love Spectre.., it is essentially a Twilight Zone episode that takes place in the TOS universe.

If there is one strong point in Spectre, it is how the mood and tone is greatly influenced by the beautiful lighting. In fact, Star Trek TOS had that one artistic quality above everybody else in my books. The use of various colors and lighting. Spectre had that in spades.
 
Nimoy is so subtle, maybe I'm seeing things that aren't there, but when Plasus introduces his daughter as a "work of art" and Spock responds that he's never met a work of art before, I think he was interested. Also, Droxy may have seem shallow, but apparently she was schooled in various art forms, like painting. It's hard to make blanket statements, but it seemed like Vulcans' had a high appreciation of art forms, so a beautiful artist may very well appeal to a Vulcan's tastes.

Also Spock is thinking this line: If the lovely Droxine knew of the young miner's misery, I wonder how the knowledge would affect her. He's thinking she's lovely.


Another quote.
SPOCK: Extreme feminine beauty is always disturbing, madam.

That's what I'm basing my previous comment on.

Maybe Spock would have like to keep her in his home on Vulcan, filing it with artwork so it's nice when he comes home on leave.
 
Nimoy *IS* subtle.

He's a big reason why watching the series all the way through (and in production order) was so rewarding.

You can get to see Spock evolve and you get to see these cool, little character traits.

My favorite example was in "Tomorrow Is Yesterday" after the big fight at the station, Spock sort of stands straight as if an idea came to him and he moves into the next room, obviously anticipating that Captain Christopher, being armed, will make a move against them. I had to rewind it to really catch it and make sure I saw what I saw.

LOVE IT!
 
Since it's come up, one of my favorite Nimoy subtle-isms is in the Changeling. When they're in the room with the map of Earth's system, and Nomad asks Kirk if his usage of the term 'creator' for him is correct, Spock cuts in with "The usage is correct. The creator was simply testing your memory banks." Nomad say "There was much damage in the accident.", then Nimoy makes a little head gesture which signals to Kirk he wants to speak with him away from Nomad.
 
I found the dialogue between Spock and Garth in Whom Gods Destroy to be so thoroughly enjoyable. The way Garth snaps and orders Spock away mid-speech was also a nice touch.
 
Since it's come up, one of my favorite Nimoy subtle-isms is in the Changeling. When they're in the room with the map of Earth's system, and Nomad asks Kirk if his usage of the term 'creator' for him is correct, Spock cuts in with "The usage is correct. The creator was simply testing your memory banks." Nomad say "There was much damage in the accident.", then Nimoy makes a little head gesture which signals to Kirk he wants to speak with him away from Nomad.

I'm not sure if it was Nimoy improvising or direction given to him, but I always liked the way Spock deflected Kirk's hands in TMP when Kirk reached out to touch the wiring, so he wouldn't burn them, "The circuits have been burnt out!" "Yes, Captain, just now." or something to that effect.
 
Heck, after all these years, I still can't figure out just what it is exactly about his portrayal of mirror-Spock that makes him a different character from the norm. :wtf:
 
Turnabout Intruder, similarly, gets witch hunted for being sexist. I think that's rather extreme. Why is it sexist? Did I miss something? ..

This episode introduced the Federation rule that women could not captain a starship.
 
Going by the TOS/TAS logic, the chain of command on USS Enterprise is:
Kirk
Spock
Scott
Sulu
Uhura
 
The Janice Lester line was discussed here last year. It is open to interpretation. I like to believe that Janice Lester feels Kirk didn't have room in his life for his career and a relationship.

Neil
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top