All depends on whether or not your defence rely on your keeper to orchestrate the defensive line. Our's do, and Bywater can't do it. Consequently, disaster waiting to happen. Your defence is much better than our's so perhaps it'll work out. Bywater's actually a pretty good shot-stopper. Other than the lack of communication skills, his only other real fault is his distribution. More often than not his kicking either goes straight out, or finds the nearest forward!