TrekLit Recommendations/Opinions

Discussion in 'Trek Literature' started by kirk55555, Jun 13, 2014.

  1. JD

    JD Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2004
    Location:
    Arizona, USA
    Watch the episode. There's a lot more to it than just him not liking adopted families.
    ETA: It's been a while since I watched the episode, but I don't remember there being any scenes that seemed to indicate that Sisko had any problems with adopted families. The issues came around because of how Rugal ended up with his adopted family, not the fact that he was adopted.
     
  2. kirk55555

    kirk55555 Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2011
    Location:
    Washington State, USA
    Well, I'd say at that point it didn't matter. He spent the majority of his life with his adopted parents. Ripping him away from them on the basis of biology was BS, and basically its like Sisko has no concept of family at all. You do not take someone away from his loving parents just because his biological Dad, who he never really knew, gets discovered. That is so unethical and completely ignores both the adopted kid and the adopted family. The biological father had no rights at that point. It sucks that he lost his kid, but at that point, Rugal hadn't been his kid in about 15-16 years.

    So, no, I won't be watching the episode. I prefer to like Sisko, I don't need to watch what sounds like his worst moment in DS9. If I want to watch horrible Star Trek episodes, I have ones I can watch and at least not end up hating any of the main characters by the end.
     
  3. JD

    JD Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2004
    Location:
    Arizona, USA
    I'm not defending the descion, I'm just saying that there is more context to the decision than just Sisko hates adopted families. I agree with you (wow, I never thought I would type those words) about it being cruel, but there it took a whole episode to get to the decision.
     
  4. KRAD

    KRAD Keith R.A. DeCandido Admiral

    Joined:
    Nov 28, 1999
    Location:
    New York City
    It is, at once, both more and less complicated than that. The episode starts out being about Rugal, but it diverts into developing the Garak/Bashir bromance (this episode is only Garak's second appearance, actually) and in exposing Dukat's political machinations, to the point where the decision about Rugal is fobbed off unconvincingly in a log entry.

    To quote myself in my rewatch of the episode for Tor.com:

    "But the biggest issue is that they totally blew the ending. I keep going over the episode and wonder on what Sisko based his decision to separate Rugal from his family and send him to Cardassia to live with his biological father. Pa’Dar wants his son back because that’s what his society tells him to do. Proka wants his son back because he loves him. For that matter, Rugal himself has made it abundantly clear, not once, but many times that he hates Cardassians, loves his parents, and wants to go back to Bajor. O’Brien tells Rugal that his wishes are important, but Sisko shows no evidence of caring about the boy’s desires in his role as arbiter. Is whatever political gain Sisko might get from doing Pa’Dar a favor worth breaking up a loving family? It’s 'Suddenly Human' all over again, except without the stabbing-incident-induced realization that nurture is at least as important as nature (and without anybody getting splurted in the face with ice cream).

    "Worse, this rather important resolution to the plotline that’s been going on all episode is made in a log entry voiceover, as if it’s an afterthought, the episode spending far too much time on the Bashir-Garak bromance and the labyrinthine plotting of Dukat to have leverage on his political enemies, and not enough on Sisko’s decision, and the impact it has on Rugal and on Proka (and in general on Bajor). And in the end, there are still Cardassian orphans stuck on Bajor who want to go home (the scene where they ask Garak if he’s there to take them is heartbreaking).

    "In the end, Sisko becomes just another powerful person whose decisions have unintended consequences to the people on the ground. We expect that of Pa’Dar and Dukat; our hero is supposed to be better than that, and we’re given absolutely no good reason why he isn’t."
     
  5. borgboy

    borgboy Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Sep 3, 2005
    It is an upsetting episode.
    It's disturbing that the Cardassian boy hates Cardassians. I can't imagine he adjusted very well back on Cardassia.
     
  6. kirk55555

    kirk55555 Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2011
    Location:
    Washington State, USA
    The Never Ending Sacrifice was pretty good.

    I like how Rugal got federation citizenship by the judge basically declaring Sisko's judgement illegal. If only an actual judge had been involved in the proceedings, but I guess that would have made too much sense :rommie:

    The very end was a bit confusing, because it seemed like they were implying that Rugal was halucinaiting his girlfriend being on Cardassia (they never say who the woman is he meets near the destroyed statue, and they had tried very hard to make clear that she was dead). I'm going to assume that was just the author getting too cute with the scene, and that I'm not supposed to think that Rugal had snapped. Still, they could have included her name in the exchange, and maybe not have hand waved her survival away. It didn't ruin the ending, but it was a bit annoying and rushed, since she just shows up and he doesn't act surprised at all.

    OVerall I enjoyed the book, with my only real complaints coming from the episode that inspired it and not the book itself. Next i'll be reading The Buried Age, and I'm sure it will be good.
     
  7. Jarvisimo

    Jarvisimo Captain Captain

    Joined:
    Jan 4, 2011
    I think Penelya is real - the ending is bittersweet, more than 'cute'. I don't think there is any sense that Rugal has 'snapped' - although I had never thought of that before, but he's too level-headed, too down-to-earth, unlike his friends who did go mad. I guess it is in the eye of the beholder, but I think Una mentioned here before about Rugal & Pen (but I may be wrong).

    Oh you should definitely read her other books - The Lotus Flower, Brinkmanship and The Crimson Shadow all deal with Cardassia, and she has such a talent for not simply Garak but also other members of that species. Her Cardassia, her rather literary (or perhaps 'indie arthouse') take on the Trek world makes me happy and sad, as it should. I just keep wanting to learn and experience more, no matter how horrifyingly real the consequences feel, as with the understandable but horrific reprisal genocides mentioned in TNS. Her landscapes too! There is this storm in The Crimson Shadow that is one of the most beautiful bits in Trek prose - this red dust that comes in and cakes the shanty city that is the capitol of Cardassia in crimson.

    Her work is an ideal, and superior, successor to Andrew J. Robinson's own lovely A Stitch in Time. Have you read it?
     
  8. kirk55555

    kirk55555 Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2011
    Location:
    Washington State, USA
    Yeah, I don't think the girlfriend was fake, the scene was just done in a weird way.

    When it comes to the author's other books, I've read Brinkmanship and The Crimson Shadow. I remember liking Brinkmanship, and The Crimson Shadow was easily the best book of The Fall series. TCS is the first book I read that was about Cardassia and Garak, and it was a great book. I didn't remember who wrote it, so I didn't realize that The Never Ending Sacrifice was by the same author. I've never read The Lotus Flower, but it looks interesting and I'd be open to more stories featuring Cardassia written by McCormack.

    I've never read A Stitch in Time, but I've heard of it and want to read it. But, its $23 used on Amazon (and $73 new), and I'm not willing to pay about 3 times the cover price for the book. Since I don't have an e-book reader, the kindle version isn't an option. I don't know why its so expensive, since most ST books, even popular ones, are pretty cheap within a year or two of release, but it is one I wish wasn't super expensive.
     
  9. BruntFCA

    BruntFCA Commander Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2011
    Location:
    A Mile High
    Cheaper copies do get listed but they sell very quickly so you have to check amazon regularly, that's what I did and after a couple weeks of checking I was able to get a "like new" copy for $8. Its definitely worth the effort.
     
  10. borgboy

    borgboy Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Sep 3, 2005
    You can download ebook to read on your pc or device. Not a method I' prefer, but still an option.
     
  11. JD

    JD Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2004
    Location:
    Arizona, USA
    Yeah, both Kindle and Nook have apps for computers, tablets and smart phones. They're all free to, so all you don't have to pay anything more than the price of the book, which is often cheaper than the paper book. I don't think very many people use e-readers any more, most people use a tablet or smart phone.
     
  12. BillJ

    BillJ Fleet Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Jan 30, 2001
    Location:
    Per Ardua
    I'd much rather use my Kindle than try to read a book on my iPad or cell phone.