TNG Hurt/Heal Game - Best Episode Season 7

Discussion in 'The Next Generation' started by Rhaenys, Aug 21, 2008.

  1. Rhaenys

    Rhaenys Lieutenant Commander Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Apr 10, 2008
    Season 6 rankings:

    1st: Tapestry
    2ns: Chain of Command
    3rd: Relics

    4th: Timescape
    5th: Chain of Command, Part I
    6th: Frame of Mind
    7th: Face of the Enemy
    8th: The Chase
    9th: Starship Mine
    10th: Birthright, Part I
    11th: Descent, Part I
    12th: Ship in a Bottle
    13th: Schisms
    14th: Lessons
    15th: Birthright, Part II
    16th: Rightful Heir
    17th: Second Chances
    18th: Realm of Fear
    19th: A Fistful of Datas
    20th: Time's Arrow, Part II
    21st: True Q
    22nd: The Quality of Life
    23rd: Man of the People
    24th: Rascals
    25th: Suspicions

    ________________________________________________

    The Rules
    • Each episode starts on 10 points.
    • 1 Vote every calendar day per member.
    • On each vote you must both:
    • Heal your favorite episode + 1
    • & Hurt your least favorite episode -2
    • (You cannot hurt without healing or vice versa)
    • Once an episode reaches zero it's out
    • Episodes are ranked in order of elimination
    • Please indicate which episodes you have voted for
    ________________________________________________

    Now vote for:

    SEASON 7:

    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 10
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 10
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 10
    Lower Decks 10
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 10
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 10
    Journey's End 10
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 10
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things, Part I 10
    All Good Things, Part II 10


    Should we split AGT in two parts, or not?
     
  2. Orac

    Orac Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Feb 22, 2007
    Location:
    Ultraworld
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 10
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 11 +
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 10
    Lower Decks 10
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 10
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 10
    Journey's End 10
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8 -
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 10
     
  3. Harvey

    Harvey Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Oct 8, 2005
    Location:
    Los Angeles, California
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 10
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 11 The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 8-
    Lower Decks 10
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 10
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 11+ :p
    Journey's End 10
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 10
     
  4. The Old Mixer

    The Old Mixer Clean Old Mod Moderator

    Joined:
    Feb 4, 2002
    Location:
    Somewhere in Connecticut
    "GENESIS"? "Genesis" is episode forbidden, voting restricted!

    Nah, I remember thinking that was a fun episode--I'm not sure why everyone has a bug up their collective butt about it.

    Jesus, it's been so long since I watched this season that I hardly know any of these episodes by name! I had to browse IMDB just to refresh my memory. This really was a pretty crappy season, wasn't it?

    I do distinctly remember that "Masks" sucked Rigellian donkey balls....


    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 10
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 12 +
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 8
    Lower Decks 10
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 8 -
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 11
    Journey's End 10
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 10
     
  5. M

    M Vice Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 10, 2007
    Don't know why everyone seems to hate this episode so much.

    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8 -
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 12
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 8
    Lower Decks 10
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 9 +
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 11
    Journey's End 10
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 10
     
  6. Geck

    Geck Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    May 22, 2000
    Location:
    Sydney, Australia
    Yeah, Masks is weird but fun if I'm in the right mood. Force of Nature, on the other hand...bottom 5 TNG eps ever?

    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 8 -
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 12
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 8
    Lower Decks 11 +
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 9
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 11
    Journey's End 10
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 10
     
  7. KeepOnTrekking

    KeepOnTrekking Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Oct 18, 2001
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 6 -
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 12
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 8
    Lower Decks 12 +
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 9
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 11
    Journey's End 10
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 10
     
  8. RaymondJames

    RaymondJames Captain Captain

    Joined:
    Jun 9, 2008
    Location:
    Japan
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 6
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 12
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 8
    Lower Decks 12
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7 (-)
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 12 (+)
    Journey's End 10
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 10
     
  9. RaymondJames

    RaymondJames Captain Captain

    Joined:
    Jun 9, 2008
    Location:
    Japan
    I ahted this episode too its in my bottom 10 for the entire 7 year run. I didn't like this episode because it was very boring and there was no action to it, it was great in consept. It showed Picard being scientist/explorer like which really is who he is underneath the red command unifourm. However it was strictly a Picard/Data episode and the rest of the cast wasn't needed at all. This episode moved slowly and was sluggish. It was cool because of its strange culture and mythology aspect which I love myself but this was not entertaining, it was like watching a PBS brodcast of paint drying.:rolleyes: I think another reason i give this episode so much gruff is because its a season7 episode (this is where hard, deep, action packed and breath taking episodes should be in full force because its the end) If this was a season 1 episode I would give it a better review.
     
  10. Natural

    Natural Captain Captain

    Joined:
    Dec 4, 2004
    Location:
    Canada
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 6
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13 +
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 8
    Lower Decks 12
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 12
    Journey's End 8 -
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 10
     
  11. Mallory

    Mallory Moderator Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 17, 2002
    Location:
    Oregon, USA
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 6
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 10
    Sub Rosa 6 -
    Lower Decks 12
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 12
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 11 +
     
  12. boognish

    boognish Captain

    Joined:
    Apr 19, 2008
    Location:
    Rising up from the mist
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 6
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 8 -
    Sub Rosa 6
    Lower Decks 12
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 13 +
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 11
     
  13. Geck

    Geck Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    May 22, 2000
    Location:
    Sydney, Australia
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 4 -
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 8
    Sub Rosa 6
    Lower Decks 13 +
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 13
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 11
     
  14. BigFoot

    BigFoot Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Sep 27, 2001
    Location:
    Slovenia (EU)
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 4
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 8
    Sub Rosa 4 -
    Lower Decks 14 +
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 13
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 11
     
  15. Bosch571

    Bosch571 Lieutenant Commander Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Feb 1, 2007
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Force of Nature 2 -
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 8
    Sub Rosa 4
    Lower Decks 15 +
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 13
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 11
     
  16. Garth Rockett

    Garth Rockett Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Jun 17, 2004
    Location:
    Flying in a Purple Dream
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 10
    Homeward 8
    Sub Rosa 4
    Lower Decks 15
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 13
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 12 +

    Eliminated:

    25th: Force of Nature -
     
  17. Renvar

    Renvar Lieutenant Commander Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Aug 18, 2008
    Location:
    Anchorage, AK
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 11 +
    Homeward 8
    Sub Rosa 2 -
    Lower Decks 15
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 13
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 12

    Eliminated:

    25th: Force of Nature
     
  18. Mallory

    Mallory Moderator Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 17, 2002
    Location:
    Oregon, USA
    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 11
    Homeward 8
    Lower Decks 15
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 7
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 13
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 13 +

    Eliminated:

    24th: Sub Rosa -
    25th: Force of Nature
     
  19. The Old Mixer

    The Old Mixer Clean Old Mod Moderator

    Joined:
    Feb 4, 2002
    Location:
    Somewhere in Connecticut
    So what makes "Force of Nature" so unpopular?


    Descent, Part II 10
    Liaisons 10
    Interface 10
    Gambit, Part I 10
    Gambit, Part II 10
    Phantasms 10
    Dark Page 8
    Attached 10
    Inheritance 10
    Parallels 13
    The Pegasus 11
    Homeward 8
    Lower Decks 16 +
    Thine Own Self 10
    Masks 5 -
    Eye of the Beholder 10
    Genesis 13
    Journey's End 8
    Firstborn 10
    Bloodlines 10
    Emergence 8
    Preemptive Strike 10
    All Good Things 13

    Eliminated:
    24th: Sub Rosa
    25th: Force of Nature
     
  20. RaymondJames

    RaymondJames Captain Captain

    Joined:
    Jun 9, 2008
    Location:
    Japan
    I will be targetings Masks for elimination if/when my time comes:devil: