Should K'Ehleyr have replaced Troi?

Discussion in 'Star Trek: The Next Generation' started by Morpheus 02, Mar 11, 2011.

?

Should K'Ehleyr have replaced Troi?

  1. Oh Yes! She would have added much to the crew & stories

    15.2%
  2. No, the death was appropriate for the story & Worf's arc

    43.5%
  3. Umm...maybe. Let's discuss it.

    17.4%
  4. Y'know, I never thought about that...

    23.9%
  1. Morpheus 02

    Morpheus 02 Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2003
    Location:
    Chicago IL
    I was just re-watching "reunion" the other day, and was just amazed at what range Suzy Plakson gave K'Ehleyr during the course of an episode. And how the character is -- she would have been so useful to Picard, in addition to being a logical person to have a relationship with (as opposed to Troi??)

    Should K'Ehleyr have replaced Troi as the Counselor (or a modified role as Captain's advisor)?

    Sure, she was an ambassador, but as we have seen, that hasn't stopped other Trek characters from taking a place on the Bridge.

    If not in this episode (which had K'Ehleyr's dramatic death, that certainly works for the story) ...then maybe an alternate K'Ehleyr somehow following Worf to the Enterprise.
     
  2. Subcommander R.

    Subcommander R. Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Jun 30, 2010
    Location:
    California
    I was torn between 'no' and 'I never thought about it.'

    And I only never thought about it because 'no.'If this makes any sense at all.
     
  3. Nerys Myk

    Nerys Myk The Real Me Premium Member

    Joined:
    Nov 4, 2001
    Location:
    Down in the tube station at midnight
    I would think she needs some sort of training to be a counselor. To my knowledge K'Ehleyr has no background in psychotherapy. As for advising the captain, he has no shortage of those. Though one skilled in diplomacy would be a plus. Wasn't Troi on the bridge because she was an empath and Picard figured that would be useful? A Captain's prerogative type thing?

    Though as an Ambassor K'Ehleyr could overrule and second guess Picard in certain situations. I can't see any Captain wanting that. I'd require her to resign her postion as an Ambassor and join Starfleet first. ;)
     
  4. WillsBabe

    WillsBabe Vice Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Dec 27, 2002
    I say no, I don't think she should have replaced Troi as counselor or a character. I do think she would have made a great regular, or reoccuring character, though.
     
  5. Mary Ann

    Mary Ann Knitting is logical Admiral

    Joined:
    Apr 16, 2010
    Location:
    A Canuck in southwest England
    As WillsBabe says, I don't think she would have been a suitable replacement for Troi, but I wish K'Ehleyr had survived as she's one of my favourite TNG characters. Even if she didn't stay on the Enterprise she could have been a recurring guest as Worf's mate, which would have also relieved us of some of the tedious scenes between Worf and Alexander.
     
  6. sonak

    sonak Vice Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Jul 13, 2007
    Location:
    in a figment of a mediocre mind's imagination
    great character, but the roles are totally different, you couldn't just swap her for Troi, it would make no sense.


    K'ehleyr doesn't strike me as a therapist, and she doesn't have Troi's empathic abilities for Picard to use as a resource.

    also she remains cool because she was used so sparingly. Regular character status would make her less interesting.
     
  7. Warped9

    Warped9 Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Aug 3, 2003
    Location:
    Brockville, Ontario, Canada
    Hmm... K'Ehleyr as Counselor.

    Crewman: Counselor, I don't know what's wrong with me. I can't seem to get motivated--

    K'Ehleyr: That is too bad. But you better get motivated or I'll kick your ass down the corridor. Or...I have an exercise program that could help with your lack of motivation. It'll keep you on your toes...

    Later, 2 minutes on the holodeck and the crewman runs screaming down the corridor...
     
    Last edited: Mar 12, 2011
  8. Morpheus 02

    Morpheus 02 Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2003
    Location:
    Chicago IL
    i wasn't necessarily think K'Ehleyr as replacing Troi as counselor...more like her place at Picard's side on the bridge.

    Troi's role there has been (it seems) like stating th eobvious, with no real benefit form her empathic powers. K'Ehleyr could do the same thing by listening to voices and watching expressions.

    i think K'Ehleyr would have created dramatic tension among the crew...enough to for us to appreciate cultural diversity (as Pulaski seemed to do)
     
  9. Trek Survivor

    Trek Survivor Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Jan 12, 2009
    Location:
    UK
    Definitely not.
     
  10. Warped9

    Warped9 Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Aug 3, 2003
    Location:
    Brockville, Ontario, Canada
    Troi was simply a bland character that was rarely used well.
     
  11. DS9

    DS9 Lieutenant Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Feb 22, 2011
    Location:
    Chicago, IL
    I don't know about counsellor, but I think K'Ehleyr should have had a more prominent or reoccurring role in TNG in some way.
     
  12. Tallifer

    Tallifer Lieutenant Commander Red Shirt

    Joined:
    Dec 31, 2010
    Location:
    Pusan, Korea
    No, Guinan should have replaced Troi.
     
  13. Warped9

    Warped9 Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Aug 3, 2003
    Location:
    Brockville, Ontario, Canada
    Yes! :techman:
     
  14. LitmusDragon

    LitmusDragon Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Sep 27, 2002
    Location:
    The Barmuda Triangle
    Nevar! I'm a Marina Sirtis fan though so I wouldn't want her replaced by anybody.
     
  15. YellowSubmarine

    YellowSubmarine Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Aug 17, 2010
    I'm not sure what to answer here.

    I never liked Troi's character too much, and how Marina Sirtis played the role. The result reminds me of the archetypal psychic – exactly the one who wouldn't have any telepathic abilities. And I was never convinced that she was suitable for her job that much, it felt as if only her telepathic abilities made her a counsellor, she seemed to lack good scientific knowledge of the mind to work as that, she was mostly used as an additional sensor on the ship – “I sense this”, “I sense that”, “I don't sense anything...” She had a few very good episodes, and she got better later on, but to me it felt like attempts to fix a character that hadn't be thought well enough and using the character's unintended flaws to the show's advantage. Oh, and they gave her an uniform and changed her hair style, both of which were significant improvements.

    And I was in love with K'Ehleyr the first time she appeared, I watched the episodes where she appeared more than a dozen times.

    But I'm not sure that she'd make a good regular, in fact I'd say she'd be worse as a regular. I'd be happy if she got more episodes in a larger arc though. And she wouldn't fit in the place of Troi, not to mention that there were many episodes that would be significantly worse if Troi wasn't there. My memory is not too good, but I think I'd miss her in “First Contact” (the movie; although she wasn't the usual Troi there), in “Parallels”, in “Disaster”, in “Thine Own Self”, and now I think to watch “Face of the Enemy” again.

    In short, I'd prefer K'Ehleyr over Troi any time, but I'd say removing Troi from the show would be a terrible idea, and bringing too much K'Ehleyr in the show might not work either. So no.
     
  16. Red Ranger

    Red Ranger Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    May 20, 2005
    Location:
    New York City, the greatest city in the world!
    Since i like Troi, I wouldn't want K'Ehleyr to replace Troi. However, it would have been cool if, in an alternate dimension, she had been a crew member, maybe even a helm officer or in one where Worf wasn't around, she could've been the security chief. I can see either position working for her.
     
  17. JRS

    JRS Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Jun 25, 2003
    Location:
    Czech Republic
    Same here:techman::)
     
  18. USS Kongo

    USS Kongo Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2006
    Even though she often got on my nerves at times with her touchy-feely manner, I still like Troi well enough, and wouldn't have wanted her to be replaced.

    I actually would have preferred to see more of Dr. Selar, a Vulcan medical doctor which Suzie also played once on TNG.

    Sean
     
  19. Morpheus 02

    Morpheus 02 Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Feb 3, 2003
    Location:
    Chicago IL
    i actually agree that Guinan would have been a more appropriate counselor, than even Troi.

    But i think K'Ehlehr had a place on Enterprise...maybe diplomatic attache, or some such excuse. i could see her as a recurring role like Keiko O'Brien, brought out as appropriate, but not needed every episode.
     
  20. Gil T.Azell

    Gil T.Azell Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Mar 11, 2005
    Location:
    Gil T.Azell
    Not sure about Troi, but maybe Tasha?