• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Ion Storms and Ion Pods

JonnyQuest037

Vice Admiral
Admiral
In "Court Martial," Kirk sends Ben Finney out in an ion pod to collect information about an oncoming ion storm, something that's apparently standard procedure at the time of this episode. The pod is jettisoned during the storm once it becomes too dangerous for the ship.

Ion storms also factor into the plots of "The Galileo Seven" and "Mirror, Mirror," but there's no mention in either episode of an ion pod being used. Do you think that this was done offscreen and just not mentioned by the characters, or did the events of "Court Martial" lead to new procedures during ion storms?
 
There was no ion storm in Galileo Seven.

In Court Martial, i think the Enterprise was deliberately going into the ion storm, it was assigned to, and it was carrying a external pod which had specialized equipment and sensors that the Enterprise itself didn't carry.
 
^^^
I disagree.

Kirk makes the point that Finney was assigned the pod duty merely because it was his turn on the rotation. That suggests that the ion pod duty was a regular feature of starship duty. Furthermore, Finney was preforming this duty as the ship's Records Officer, which suggests that no intensive ion pod mission specific training is involved to do the job. This suggests that the events of "Court Martial" were not out of the ordinary before Finney began his dastardly plot.

I see no reason to expect that there weren't crewmen in ion pods during the other instances of ion storms, but just that things went down as per protocol and it never was dramatically important enough to mention on-screen.

--Alex
 
^ I agree.

Also, I would like to add, the Haulkan mission was a diplomatic mission that could have had a pod person (wait is that right?) observing, but it wasn't the primary focus, also, the shuttle was the primary information gathering apparatus in Galaleo Seven, so a pod person, again, wouldn't be the primary focus.
 
I thought one of the cool additions to the CGI versio was a shot of the Enterprise up close where you see an area where the pod had blasted out from.
 
I always figured the ion pod was a mission-specific thing, that they needed to get readings on the storm for some reason. It seems kind of stupid otherwise, to routinely put a crew member in a position where a couple of seconds' delay can get them shot into space. Not to mention one of the ship's top officers.

Obviously Don Mankiewicz was going for a "man overboard, lost at sea, no body was found" scenario, but that's hard to apply to a sealed-up spaceship, so he came up with this jettisonable pod idea. In an early draft, the pod was a routinely-manned observation post, like a crow's nest, and in the storm has to be jettisoned because it protrudes and makes the ship unstable. What, in space? In the Blish version, which has no doubt influenced my thinking on this episode, part of their assignment is to gather scientific information on the storm, and the problem is the pod builds up a charge of some kind that will endanger the whole ship. Either way the whole thing is kind of goofy.
 
Why did they have to jettison the pod in the first place with a man inside anyway? I mean to say what's the emergency or rush to get information over a man's life?
JB
 
The Pod was doing, or causing, something that created a danger to the ship. Kept the shields from operating normally, or the ship's malnuvering ability was reduced by it's presence, or sometime else.

We don't know how big it was and it could have been quite large, attached to the side of the ship, and in the environment of the storm caused a "drag" on the ship.
 
I think he came up on the duty roster not as the next guy in the ion pod, but the next to do something risky like that .
 
The real issue with the ion pod is that the writers couldn't think far enough ahead. Computers were starting to become common--business and government wise--in the '60s--and while some had very forward ideas of what computers might one day be able to do they also had blind spots.

Today such a thing as an ion pod--even if such a thing were necessary--could be run completely by computer control and without endangering anyone.
 
but the next to do something risky like that
Or the next who was qualified for such duty.

If (as I suppect) the Enterprise was "storm chasing" then they might have investigated many storms. Going deeper into each subsequent storm. Other crewmembers had been in the pod, Finney name just came up.

Or Finney malnipulated the duty roster to put him in the pod with the anticipation that the next storm entry was going to be one where the pod would likely be jettisoned. This would be part of a existing plan to discredit Kirk.

Or Finney really hadn't plan the whole thing out, but a soon as he was out of the pod and it was jettisoned behind him he recognized an opportunity, and went into hiding, and altered the records.
 
The real issue with the ion pod is that the writers couldn't think far enough ahead. Computers were starting to become common--business and government wise--in the '60s--and while some had very forward ideas of what computers might one day be able to do they also had blind spots.

Today such a thing as an ion pod--even if such a thing were necessary--could be run completely by computer control and without endangering anyone.

By the mid-1960s, both the USSR and USA had already launched several unmanned probes of the moon, Venus, Mars, and solar orbits. A few of them had even been successful. It was clear unmanned probes were the way to go for risky missions. The writers just had trouble filling plot holes.
 
I love it when this subject rolls around again! :beer:

A further line of thought about the ion pod: what if it was part of a system designed to help disperse the ion storm ahead of the ship? It would still require someone to go in and manually calibrate the payload systems (in a computer free, anti static environment or something) but ejection would still be a necessary and inevitable part of the process.
If time was running out and the storm was getting worse, Kirk literally had to eject the pod in order to save the ship - which is why he would do it again, without question (as he says to Commodore Stone)
 
It's pretty standard tornado hunter stuff, really. Whether it was written with that intent or not is quite irrelevant, as the interpretation makes obvious and intuitive sense.

Kirk sailed deliberately into an ion storm when he clearly could have avoided it (the ship is approaching the storm and not vice versa, says the helmsman), and initially made no attempt to leave ("hold your course"). He was keeping close watch on how the threat to the ship gradually increased, and was going to cut and run, but only after achieving something.

What he did wait for in actual fact was the jettisoning of the pod. He even had his command panel configured for that very action. It thus very much seems this was his mission objective: to jettison the pod. It just had to be prepared first, by somebody suitably competent, but he had no standing specialist for the task, apparently because it was a very rare one. And the preparing had to happen while the ship was already flying into the storm because of the same thing: the rare storm would dissipate if Kirk waited to prepare the pod first.

Ben Finney counted on an ion storm for his dastardly plot. But he had been plotting for years! Storms thus do appear to be relatively rare things. (Or was Finney skipping eighteen storms and waiting for the nineteenth so that him having the pod shift would not look too suspicious?)

That the pod would pose a danger to the ship is never indicated. The storm poses a threat. But the ship has to stay inside the storm until deploying the properly primed pod.

What part is left unclear or mysterious?

Or Finney really hadn't plan the whole thing out, but a soon as he was out of the pod and it was jettisoned behind him he recognized an opportunity, and went into hiding, and altered the records.

This is a less preferable interpretation, as what Finney did does require some preparation. He needed his place of hiding, for one thing, and he couldn't prepare it after the fact, while a thorough search was going on "in and around the ship".

As for the ion storm in "The Galileo Seven", we have two things to consider:

1) Kirk already had two pressing priorities there, the delivery of the medicine and the rescue of his missing team. Combined, enough reason to skip scientific research? Clearly, the medicine matter alone didn't stop Kirk from studying the Murasaki phenomenon and region, and the local ion storms might in fact have been part of the attraction.

2) Kirk nevertheless didn't send his ship in there, but a shuttle. Perhaps there are limits to what dangers a starship may brave in order to get ion storm data, and Murasaki just upped the ante too high?

In "Mirror, Mirror", there was no mention of a storm - except in the Mirror universe! The Imperial approach to storms might have been to avoid them unless flying through one made tactical sense in combat (or made the skipper look brave).

Timo Saloniemi
 
Or Finney malnipulated the duty roster to put him in the pod with the anticipation that the next storm entry was going to be one where the pod would likely be jettisoned. This would be part of a existing plan to discredit Kirk.

That's a great point, I don't know why I didn't think of that myself, with the ability to alter the logs, juggling a roster isn't really a hard task and one of the complaints I've heard about the "plot" is how likely is it they would be investigating an ion storm with his name on the top of the roster.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top