Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Cheney)

Discussion in 'Battlestar Galactica & Caprica' started by randomfan86, Apr 2, 2013.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Stoo

    Stoo Captain Captain

    Joined:
    Feb 27, 2013
    Location:
    phobos lab
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    What, that she scorched one of the last little bits of what she was meant to be protecting in the first place? A duty that was far more important than "strike back at the cylons at all costs"?
     
  2. stj

    stj Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Dec 27, 2006
    Location:
    the real world
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    Guerrilla warfare is an omnibus term covering both strategies and tactics. The strategy may be attrition, or it may aim at slowly accreting forces to engage in decisive conventional war. The tactics include hiding amongst the civilian population; attacking from difficult terrain; refusal of combat on any terms but those favoring quick victory; a continous series of small attacks. There are whole manuals spelling out guerrilla warfare tactics, including the urban variants.

    However, none of this applies to either Galactica nor Pegasus. The series' commitment to a fantasy version of current events is misleading. What Anders and Helo were doing on Caprica was the only guerrilla war showed in the series. Attacks on base ships are plain old war.

    PS As to the supposition that the dictator Park was responsible for the south's economic development? It is a dubious idea. Park was not the first dictator in the south, but Syngman Rhee didn't spark an economic boom. As an alternative hypothesis, let me suggest that the US military spending on the Vietnam War, much of which was necessarily spent in East Asia generally, was more likely to have played a key role. Japan's similar economic speed up in economic development without the supposed benefits of dictatorship in roughly the same period strongly suggests this was more important. Korean chaebol were modeled on Japanese zaibatsu and Korean economic policy as I understood it were similarly modeled on Japanese economic policy. None were the creations of dictators.

    May I further suggest that the desire to retroactively rehabilitate Park has more to do with justifying a war in Korea than historical truth? (If you say I cna't, just unread this question!)
     
  3. Robert Maxwell

    Robert Maxwell Comfortably Numb Premium Member

    Joined:
    Jun 12, 2001
    Location:
    where it hurts
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    That is a despicable attitude.

    Several US Presidents were/are war criminals and should be rotting in prison. The fact that they aren't is not a vindication of their methods, but a sad statement on the political impossibility of prosecuting American Presidents for how they conduct foreign affairs. We'll happily impeach a President for doing stupid things domestically, but we almost always give conduct related to foreign policy, and war in particular, a free pass.

    That does not in any way excuse it, and that you think it does is frightening.
     
  4. randomfan86

    randomfan86 Lieutenant

    Joined:
    Apr 1, 2013
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    Gotta go to work. Will address other posts tom. Hope I also get some support from the many Cain fans that I know are out there.
     
  5. lurok

    lurok Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Mar 15, 2011
    Location:
    Lost in the EU expanse with a nice cup of tea
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    Love Cain the character and actor who played her. Her actions? Not so much.
     
  6. randomfan86

    randomfan86 Lieutenant

    Joined:
    Apr 1, 2013
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    Park was the one who implemented and managed the policies and his people are the ones who give him credit for the success that was generated by it. Over 10% growth for more than a decade. He is considered a great leader.

    My point of mentioning Park is that he also tortured/oppressed/murdered his own people but since he was considered to be a great leader, for the SK people: the good outweighed the bad. So it should be for Cain.
     
  7. Avon

    Avon Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    May 7, 2010
    Location:
    Avon
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    and how is that relevant to cains situation in any way?

    she may have been crazy, but boy did the pegasus have a good economy!
     
  8. randomfan86

    randomfan86 Lieutenant

    Joined:
    Apr 1, 2013
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    how is what relavent? My point is that the torture/oppression/murder can be overlooked if you have a good leader.
     
  9. Avon

    Avon Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    May 7, 2010
    Location:
    Avon
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    so how was she this 'good leader? the torture/oppression/murder bit kind of ruins that

    she was only leader because under the circumstances there was no way to get rid of her
     
  10. Robert Maxwell

    Robert Maxwell Comfortably Numb Premium Member

    Joined:
    Jun 12, 2001
    Location:
    where it hurts
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    Right and wrong are still right and wrong no matter whether someone is held accountable for their crimes.

    Saying "Cain did no worse than other military/political leaders" is meaningless, because when they did it, it was wrong, too.

    Just because some human rights violators get away with it doesn't mean they didn't violate anyone's rights.
     
  11. Marc

    Marc Fleet Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Nov 14, 2003
    Location:
    An Aussie in Canukistan
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    No it gets overlooked for ideological differences. Leaders (dictators) like park and Pinochet are supported not because of what they did but the political stances they took I.e they are still admired today because of their oppression of those on the political left.
     
  12. diankra

    diankra Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    Jun 22, 2005
    Location:
    UK
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    Or hated for that reason - let's be balanced here ;)
     
  13. Marc

    Marc Fleet Admiral Admiral

    Joined:
    Nov 14, 2003
    Location:
    An Aussie in Canukistan
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    that would defeat the purpose.

    Pak is being held up an example of some-one how used Cain-like tactics i.e brutality and is supposedly still respected for what he turned South Korea into.

    But that respect would only really come from those who shared his ideology (same a Pinochet was supported and admired till his death by Reagan and Thatcher for anti-communist stance). The rest deplore him for his atrocities the same same as Cain is deplored for her behavior no matter what what victories she might have acehived.

    Her summary execution of the her XO is again something out of a dictatorial regieme. Sure even in the U.S armed services you might get the death penalty for such an act, it's not you're going to get court martial and the right to be heard.

    In fact it's more likely Cain who would have ended up in the daggit shit for her actions and that the XO was right in refusing to carry out her orders.
     
  14. stj

    stj Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Dec 27, 2006
    Location:
    the real world
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    My post gave reasons to believe that other people could have and would have implemented the same policies without the dictatorship. Your posts either assume that Park is responsible or cite some unknown subjects who consider Park a great leader. And I gave a good reason for that so-called opinion, the desire for war to reunify Korea on some southern leaders' preferred terms.

    Since this is one of your key points, the inability to even attempt a refutations strongly suggests you're dead wrong. The Park example does not support you. Nor does the Cheney example. You may be correct that the show itself insists that Cain is not just a villain whose demise we are to cheer. At least, no one seems to have argued that point successfully. But what the show thinks is irrelevant to what we decide is right in the real world, and anyone has the right to apply the same reasoning to their opinion of a fictional character.

    Balance? Right wing leaders routinely use violence and fear (despite the formal illegality in most cases) on behalf of a minority. In practice, a popular government rarely can take power because the right wing forcibly suppresses majority rule. It is unbalanced to claim that minority repression of the majority is morally equivalent to alleged majority suppression of the majority. Death squads are an integral part of right wing regimes, but not of left ones. That's not balanced either.
     
  15. Locutus of Bored

    Locutus of Bored The Mod Awakens Moderator

    Joined:
    Jul 5, 2004
    Location:
    Huntington Beach, California
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    You know who else aided and abetted a genocide? Admiral Cain, by murdering civilians, crippling their ships and abandoning them to die, separating families who could be having more children, and pursuing a hopeless war of vengeance that already got a third of her crew killed and would have killed the rest had it kept going.

    It was as much about getting revenge on the Cylon woman who hurt and deceived her as it was about getting information. Probably an element of embarrassment at being tricked since she's a raging egomaniac as well.

    And torture is wrong regardless of who uses it. It doesn't become okay just because you consider yourselves the good guys. Everyone considers themselves the good guys.

    Raiding the ships for parts and personnel has nothing to do with scorched Earth warfare, it was about prolonging her pointless vengeance war and being a sociopath who doesn't care about how her actions affect others.

    As you say, scorched Earth is about denying the enemy resources, either by destroying their resources if you're on the offensive (Sherman's March to the Sea) or destroying your resources if you're on the defensive (the USSR during the German invasion). But the Cylon's weren't interested in taking human resources and tech, they were interested in killing all humans at that point. So your comparison to scorched Earth warfare makes no sense. Nor does your defense of Cain's strategy and tactics, since she was so blinded by hate that she actually aided the Cylons in their goal of destroying humanity.

    So, yeah, I'll judge her harshly.

    The fact that Adama and Starbuck complimented Cain keeps getting mentioned as if that should close out the argument or something.

    First of all, since when are Adama and Starbuck unimpeachable paragons of virtue? They've both done some pretty morally questionable things themselves. Nothing even close to being on par with what Cain did, but their hands certainly aren't clean, nor are they infallible.

    Secondly, it's a lot easier to judge someone less harshly when she's dead and no longer a constant threat hanging over you and your crew.

    Thirdly, they were trying to integrate a hostile crew who had nearly been in a firefight with them days earlier into their command structure. Badmouthing their former commander at her funeral doesn't seem like a great way of building a bridge between the crews, especially since that hostility still existed two years later and boiled over into mutiny for many of them.

    Lee is self-righteous for rightly pointing out that Kendra Shaw was a murderer? Jesus Christ.

    Fighting for what home? Their home was destroyed. The two ragtag fleets were all they had left to call home, and Cain crippled hers and left them to die. How did she fight for them?

    In case you forgot, at first Earth was just something Adama said to give the people hope and keep them pacified until he could figure something out. It was only later that the search for it became serious when they started finding clues. The goal initially was just to get clear of the Cylons and possibly find a habitable planet to settle on where they might start over again. Adama and Roslin were fighting for a home, in the form of saving the surviving humans of the fleet and rebuilding their society. Cain was fighting for pointless vengeance.

    So, yeah, I will judge her for that. Her tactics and strategy were stupid, pointless, and immoral.

    You know, Godwin's Law doesn't really apply when you're discussing things that Hitler and the Nazis actually did, like committing war crimes and genocide. It's not meant to be a ban on mentioning Hitler or the Nazis even when they're relevant to the discussion.

    Also, repeating the same thing over and over again doesn't make it so. You've done that a lot.

    Case in point:

    It's not a strawman if that's an actual argument you've been making throughout the thread, which it is. You've been an apologist for her war crimes throughout the thread based on the flimsiest of reasons, such as (paraphrasing) "other countries have done it, so it's okay" "Adama complimented her tactics, so it's okay," "if your people approve of you, rape and torture are defensible," and "she was fighting a guerrilla war, so the ends justify the means."

    She left thousands of her own people to die when the entirety of the human species was only measured in the thousands itself (and even less from her perspective than from others since she didn't know about the Adama/Roslin ragtag fleet). That is unforgivable, and certainly not "pretty mild" in any context.

    That's a pretty repugnant viewpoint. Just because something's legal at the time doesn't always make it right. Justifying FDR's racist internment of innocent Japanese-Americans simply because it was found to be constitutional is disgusting.

    Why do you keep calling her tactically competent? She walked into an obvious trap on the Cylon relay and was so blinded by rage that she continued the attack anyway and wound up losing a third of her crew.

    She murdered the only officer willing to stand up to her, thus scaring everyone else into submission and making sure she would never get an honest assessment of a battle plan or her orders again.

    She was willing to go to war with her own people over her favorite rapist accidentally being killed.

    She left a third of what was left of the human species at that point to die at the hands of the Cylons so she could pursue a vengeance war that could never possibly be won.

    Not only was she morally bankrupt, she was an idiot.

    Mind you, this is no reflection on Michelle Forbes or her performance, which was superb.

    One would think those things should disqualify you from being a "good leader," but hey, what do I know?
     
  16. DalekJim

    DalekJim Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Jun 22, 2009
    Location:
    Great Britain
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    As do left-wing leaders, historically speaking (Hi USSR!). The key isn't really their politics but more the fact they're leaders. Leaders will always work primarily on behalf of a minority because they belong to that elite minority. It is human nature.

    That isn't genocide. Genocide is the systematic destruction of a race. Cain wanted to protect humans.
     
  17. Avon

    Avon Commodore Commodore

    Joined:
    May 7, 2010
    Location:
    Avon
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che


    so she protected them by murdering them? what?!

    how does that even work??

    i suppose it might not be technically genocide, but how did you come to form that last sentence?
     
  18. Silvercrest

    Silvercrest Rear Admiral Rear Admiral

    Joined:
    Oct 4, 2003
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che


    And she did a great job of it.
     
  19. hyzmarca

    hyzmarca Fleet Captain Fleet Captain

    Joined:
    Feb 9, 2009
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    Cain is an example of Hard Men Making Hard Decisions. As with most Hard Men Making Hard Decisions, those decisions are stupid and needlessly brutal. Hard Men Making Hard Decisions are rightfully mocked for their incompetence. If the writers don't know that the Hard Men Making Hard Decisions are incompetent, that just makes it more mock-worthy.
     
  20. Neroon

    Neroon Mod of Balance Moderator

    Joined:
    Oct 31, 2000
    Location:
    On my ship the Rocinante
    Re: Defending Admiral Cain from Battlestar Galactica(mentions Dick Che

    Take it easy there. We're starting to dip too far into political harangue.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.