RSS iconTwitter iconFacebook icon

The Trek BBS title image

The Trek BBS statistics

Threads: 138,954
Posts: 5,391,025
Members: 24,722
Currently online: 509
Newest member: Jadakiss

TrekToday headlines

Forbes Cast In Powers
By: T'Bonz on Aug 22

Dorn To Voice Firefly Character
By: T'Bonz on Aug 22

No ALS Ice Bucket For Saldana
By: T'Bonz on Aug 22

Free Star Trek Trexels Game
By: T'Bonz on Aug 22

New Trek-themed Bobble Heads
By: T'Bonz on Aug 21

IDW Publishing November Trek Comic
By: T'Bonz on Aug 20

Pegg/Wright Trilogy In The Works
By: T'Bonz on Aug 20

Star Trek: The Compendium Rebate Details
By: T'Bonz on Aug 20

Gold Key Archives Volume 2
By: T'Bonz on Aug 19

Takei Documentary Wins Award
By: T'Bonz on Aug 19


Welcome! The Trek BBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans. Please login to see our full range of forums as well as the ability to send and receive private messages, track your favourite topics and of course join in the discussions.

If you are a new visitor, join us for free. If you are an existing member please login below. Note: for members who joined under our old messageboard system, please login with your display name not your login name.


Go Back   The Trek BBS > Star Trek Movies > Star Trek Movies XI+

Star Trek Movies XI+ Discuss J.J. Abrams' rebooted Star Trek here.

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old July 29 2013, 05:26 AM   #61
Neumann
Captain
 
Neumann's Avatar
 
Location: Caracas, Venezuela
View Neumann's Twitter Profile Send a message via Windows Live Messenger to Neumann
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

The Vengeance would have been able to sustain for some time the Narada attacking yet it wouldn't have been able to defeat her.
__________________
It's all about canon being violated! ;-)
Neumann is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 29 2013, 02:17 PM   #62
Timo
Admiral
 
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

Just destroying a 47-ship Klingon armada, all the other ships sent to Vulcan, etc.
Those feats took place after Nero acquired his red matter, though. And off camera at that. We don't even know whether Nero destroyed any Klingon ships for real: the report of such destruction supposedly sends Starfleet away from defending Vulcan and Earth, and the timing is so good this must be a Nero-engineered ruse. Why would Nero bother to involve real Klingons in his ruse, rather than just a false message?

(We do know he is in the habit of sending false messages. The SOS from Vulcan must have been Nero's doing as well, because there was no geological instability when it was sent; the drill only began drilling later on, with the fleet already en route, as we saw when Amanda rushed to the balcony.)

The two times Nero's ship tried to tackle a shielded vessel, she took her sweet time to get any visible results - the first time almost getting rammed as the result. The Narada was no combatant, apparently, unable to sustain fire or take much return fire. She was simply a big platform to fire from.

Why this would prompt Starfleet to take any action is another unanswered question. The mining rigs of future madmen should not be a strategic concern to the organization!

Timo Saloniemi
Timo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 29 2013, 08:01 PM   #63
Set Harth
Rear Admiral
 
Set Harth's Avatar
 
Location: Police State
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

Timo wrote: View Post
Those feats took place after Nero acquired his red matter, though.
One of them would have been before he acquired the red matter, but it doesn't matter, because he didn't use the red matter to accomplish them, just the missiles on his ship.

Timo wrote:
And off camera at that.
That's irrelevant, especially in the case of the Federation fleet: we see their wreckage.

Timo wrote:
We don't even know whether Nero destroyed any Klingon ships for real
That plot point is, of course, a relic of the prison planet escape plotline from the deleted scenes. As such, it was assuredly meant to be a real incident before that plotline was effectively cut from the film. So the Narada was considered strong enough to do that at that point. Are we to assume that when the prison escape material was cut from the film the Narada was made weaker as a result?
__________________
Player: I thought you were dead.
Revan: Only somewhat.
Set Harth is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 29 2013, 08:18 PM   #64
Timo
Admiral
 
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

One of them would have been before he acquired the red matter, but it doesn't matter, because he didn't use the red matter to accomplish them, just the missiles on his ship.
Both were quoted as happening after Nero's encounter with Spock; the writers were kind enough to provide an hour-by-hour timeline...

"At twenty-two hundred hours, telemetry detected at an anomaly in the neutral zone. What appeared to be a lightning storm in space."
That's Spock arriving with the red matter.

"At twenty-three hundred hours last night, there was an attack. Forty-seven Klingon warbirds destroyed by a Romulan, Sir.
That's the putative Klingon battle. And this dialogue takes place while Nero is slaughtering the cadet fleet.

Also, since both battles were off screen, we can't tell what weapons were used.

That's irrelevant, especially in the case of the Federation fleet: we see their wreckage.
And? It doesn't significantly differ from the wreckage created when red matter destroys Nero's own vessel.

(It would also involve lower doses of red matter, meaning fewer and shorter-lasting black holes around... The one(s) from the arrivals of the ships from the 24th century was minuscule and a brief candle, and the one left over when Vulcan fell was invisibly small, too. Just use a couple of drops rather than one, and even fifty ships are no tribble at all.)

Are we to assume that when the prison escape material was cut from the film the Narada was made weaker as a result?
This would be a merciful assumption, as the movie elsewhere makes it clear the Narada is not powerful enough to defeat even a single starship with its missile weapons. The mining rig is nearly destroyed by the Kelvin despite a protracted bombardment, and can offer no resistance to the Enterprise the second time around.

Also, it is superbly consistent that Nero send false messages, as his Vulcan one is evident. Why would this simple miner change his modus operandi? He is obsessed with kidnapping people for information, and using that information as a weapon. A message from a "Klingon prison planet" would be another piece that falls neatly in place.

Timo Saloniemi
Timo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 29 2013, 09:50 PM   #65
Set Harth
Rear Admiral
 
Set Harth's Avatar
 
Location: Police State
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

Timo wrote:
the movie elsewhere makes it clear the Narada is not powerful enough to defeat even a single starship with its missile weapons.
That's clearly not the intent of the film. The idea is that many starships were destroyed by its missile weapons. It's just that not everyone gets the idea to ram them like George Kirk and Spock did. You cited the reduction to 32% of shields yourself; the corollary to that was another hit would take them out. It's not too hard to imagine that, in the event things had not played out the way they did.

Timo wrote:
and can offer no resistance to the Enterprise the second time around.
When it's being consumed by a red matter black hole? How is that relevant to the question of its capabilities under normal circumstances?

Timo wrote:
Also, it is superbly consistent that Nero send false messages, as his Vulcan one is evident. Why would this simple miner change his modus operandi? He is obsessed with kidnapping people for information, and using that information as a weapon. A message from a "Klingon prison planet" would be another piece that falls neatly in place.
Except it serves no purpose from his POV, only alerting others to the fact that there's a big ship going around wreaking havoc. So why be coy when it comes to Vulcan? It is thus highly inconsistent. Sending out a message about Rura Penthe - even going so far as to specify an attack by a Romulan vessel! - would seem to run counter to his purposes, if those include deception regarding Vulcan. This is borne out by Kirk piecing things together while in big-hands mode and thus getting Pike to at least come out of warp with shields up. And again, the original idea in the script was that the battle at Rura Penthe was what happened when Nero and his crew escaped. Does it become a fake message just because the relevant scenes were cut? More to the point, does the Narada become a weaker ship?
__________________
Player: I thought you were dead.
Revan: Only somewhat.

Last edited by Set Harth; July 29 2013 at 10:18 PM.
Set Harth is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 29 2013, 10:19 PM   #66
Timo
Admiral
 
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

That's clearly not the intent of the film.
But it is the content of the film. Ideas don't count, or else Genesis was invented by Ruth Wallace and Spock was a red man from Mars.

When it's being consumed by a red matter black hole?
No, when it is engaged in a desperate battle with a midget spacecraft a few seconds before the red matter detonation. Clearly, the mining rig is incapable of coping with most opponents in a "fair fight", but excels in getting the drop on them and defeating them before there's risk of retribution...

Except it serves no purpose from his POV, only alerting others to the fact that there's a big ship going around wreaking havoc.
He has to create that impression if his ship isn't capable of creating havoc. He can't get rid of all of Starfleet by fighting it with a ship that runs out of ammo after twenty shots (as seen in the final battle). But he can lie to Starfleet about a really big threat somewhere far away, so that he only needs to tackle a few ships crewed by the Fleet's worst and dimmest.

Does it become a fake message just because the relevant scenes were cut?
Not just because of that, but also because Nero should be behaving exactly like that, considering the resources he possesses.

Nero's subterfuge ought to work like a dream in general terms. What confuses the issue is Chekov's brilliant, completely out-of-the-left-field mention of a thunderstorm at the Neutral Zone in connection with his public announcement about the mission to Vulcan. Why should those two be connected? Supposedly because the Neutral Zone is relatively close to Vulcan, and because the thunderstorm happened at roughly the same time as the reported trouble at Vulcan. There's no obvious reason why the thunderstorm would cause seismic trouble at Vulcan - but by mentioning this, Chekov makes it possible for Kirk to realize Starfleet is barking the wrong tree.

Not that it does any real good, of course. But if all the cadet ships dropped out of warp with shields up, the Narada would have been in trouble - it would take three times nine hits to kill them all, and that's more than the mining rig can fire at one go ("Fire EVERYTHING!"). That is, unless the carnage was achieved by dropping some red matter on their path - a move that doesn't work with surprise arrivals such as the delayed Enterprise.

If all the Starfleet forces that left Earth for Laurentius were part of the relief force, Nero would be in more than just "trouble"... Killing about fifty ships, be they Starfleet or Klingon, might still be possible with red matter although definitely not with the missiles, but it would expose Nero's precious drill to unacceptable danger (unless he delayed deploying it, but then he wouldn't have the nice jamming effect).

Timo Saloniemi
Timo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 29 2013, 10:54 PM   #67
Set Harth
Rear Admiral
 
Set Harth's Avatar
 
Location: Police State
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

Timo wrote: View Post
But it is the content of the film.
No. "Nero destroys starships using red matter" is not the content of the film.

Timo wrote:
No, when it is engaged in a desperate battle with a midget spacecraft a few seconds before the red matter detonation.
But you said it could offer no resistance to the Enterprise. Now it sounds like you're talking about the Jellyfish, which only gets close enough to ram Nero due to the Enterprise shooting down the missiles targeting it. We were told outright what would happen if several missiles hit the Enterprise.

Timo wrote:
Clearly, the mining rig is incapable of coping with most opponents in a "fair fight"
Most opponents don't try to suicidally crash into it ( and as we've seen, even that doesn't destroy it, unless the kamikaze ship is equipped with red matter ). Besides, what counts as a "fair fight"?

Timo wrote:
But he can lie to Starfleet about a really big threat somewhere far away
A threat in Klingon space, that they don't exactly have a mandate to go traipsing around in? That they wouldn't be expected to do anything about? How does that in any way affect the Federation response at Vulcan, other than in needlessly running the risk that someone figures out the Vulcan situation is a trap?

Timo wrote:
That is, unless the carnage was achieved by dropping some red matter on their path
It doesn't look like it. That appears to be a bunch of ships shot up by missiles, not a bunch of ships sucked into a red matter black hole. When Vulcan was destroyed, or when the Narada was destroyed, they didn't leave "carnage" behind.

Timo wrote:
a move that doesn't work with surprise arrivals such as the delayed Enterprise.
Enterprise is really no more of a surprise arrival than the other ships, unless you think Nero can somehow precisely calculate Starfleet response time.

Timo wrote:
Not just because of that
In the script, as opposed to the final version of the film, the timeline is different. The message about the Rura Penthe battle comes first, then the "lightning storm" of Spock's emergence. This shows that from the POV of the script the Narada was intended to be strong enough to destroy a Klingon armada without the red matter, and IMO it seems dubious to assume that the ship was rendered incapable of doing so just because the Rura Penthe scenes were deleted.
__________________
Player: I thought you were dead.
Revan: Only somewhat.
Set Harth is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 30 2013, 04:26 AM   #68
anotherdemon
Lieutenant Junior Grade
 
anotherdemon's Avatar
 
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

Narada is in an entirely different weight range than Vengeance.

One torpedo from Narada took Enterprise's shields down to 32% whilst also punching through the hull and causing internal damage. Sulu states that they can't take another hit like that, leading us to believe that the ship will be at least severely damaged/combat ineffective from a second torpedo (interesting to note that Enterprise narrowly missed one torpedo whilst catching the first one). Shields gone and the rest of the energy expended into the hull from the hit.

Not to mention the utter massacre of the fleet that arrived moments before Enterprise. One could say that their shields were down and Narada launched a couple of torpedoes at each as soon as they entered range (which they were within as soon as they exited warp). That's the worst case scenario for the fleet. It'd be likely that some of the ships raised shields and returned fire, as we never saw Narada fire its torpedoes at various targets at once, and the torpedoes were slow enough to alert crews to raise shields.

Vengeance fired several shots at an already crippled (to some extent) Enterprise, knocking it out of warp and making it combat ineffective (I think it fired some more at Enterprise before Carol spoke, but I forget). Then later on, Vengeance let loose on Enterprise for quite some time with phasers and drones (with various weapons). Enterprise was still capable of regaining impulse though, and it was mostly intact. Compare that to the fleet at Vulcan that were blown apart.

Whilst Narada isn't as spectacular as something like Scimitar (or whatever), but that's comparing a maximum warship against a mining vessel from the same period.

Last edited by anotherdemon; July 30 2013 at 06:40 AM.
anotherdemon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 30 2013, 03:46 PM   #69
Chemahkuu
Vice Admiral
 
Chemahkuu's Avatar
 
Location: United Kingdom
Send a message via Yahoo to Chemahkuu
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

The only thing wrong with the Enterprise at all during her escape from the Vengeance was her warp drive was not 100% operational due to one coolant feed being sabotaged.

Her shields, hull, weapons, vital systems were all functioning at space dock fresh state. Vengeance's phasers reacted as though the shields weren't even there at all, not just blowing up but fully vapourising entire sections of the Enterprise's hull, opening up the saucer, taking tens of meters of hull right off the starboard nacelle like it was paper, and opened a 20 meter high hole right through to the enginnering section.

Following up she punched at least one hole right down through the thickest part of the saucer section and ripped huge gaping holes decks deep into other areas, and exposing half the warp coils in the engines.

The Narada's missiles didn't even leave visible marks from direct strikes on her.
Chemahkuu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 30 2013, 04:28 PM   #70
King Daniel Into Darkness
Admiral
 
King Daniel Into Darkness's Avatar
 
Location: England again
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

Narada's missile hit on the Enterprise's neck was visible for the rest of the movie, particularly in the warp core ejection scene. From dialogue in the movie, a second hit would have been the end - and the only thing that prevented it was Nero recognizing the Enterprise as Spock's ship.
__________________
Star Trek Imponderables, fun mashups of Trek's biggest continuity errors! Ep1, Ep2 and Ep3
King Daniel Into Darkness is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 30 2013, 07:29 PM   #71
Chemahkuu
Vice Admiral
 
Chemahkuu's Avatar
 
Location: United Kingdom
Send a message via Yahoo to Chemahkuu
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

King Daniel Into Darkness wrote: View Post
Narada's missile hit on the Enterprise's neck was visible for the rest of the movie, particularly in the warp core ejection scene. From dialogue in the movie, a second hit would have been the end - and the only thing that prevented it was Nero recognizing the Enterprise as Spock's ship.
One minor black mark on the exterior. Not a gaping wound the likes of what Vengeance could dole out without any effort.

And I really don't get "ohnoes teh second missel and werh dead" bit. For the entire rest of the movie they act as if the first missle hit did literally nothing to the Enterprise, everything works, all systems are online, the only person dead is the never seen doctor needed to make McCoy be promoted, basically they titled over a little, now everythings ok.

It's not like the shields did anything to save any other ship before, no indication that anything was actually protecting the Enterprise in either movie other than her own hull.

Just really did not buy that line.
Chemahkuu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 30 2013, 07:44 PM   #72
King Daniel Into Darkness
Admiral
 
King Daniel Into Darkness's Avatar
 
Location: England again
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

There were radiation leaks in the lower levels occupying most of the engineering staff and limited the ship to warp 4, half of sickbay was destroyed, something terrible happened on deck six... yeah, the external damage doesn't quite mesh up with all that, but it's a pretty extensive damage report. And after what happened to the Federation and Klingon fleets, I think it's fair to say another hit really would have blasted the Enterprise into space dust.
__________________
Star Trek Imponderables, fun mashups of Trek's biggest continuity errors! Ep1, Ep2 and Ep3
King Daniel Into Darkness is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 30 2013, 07:54 PM   #73
Chemahkuu
Vice Admiral
 
Chemahkuu's Avatar
 
Location: United Kingdom
Send a message via Yahoo to Chemahkuu
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

It looks like the missile managed to borrow under the hull and explode, causing a lot more damage on the inside, which doesn't help when we're never shown any of it and just meant to believe that because they all wobbled a little they're all going to die.

But there was something far more terrifying about how Vengeance can just, well essentially make entire parts of a ship bigger than the Sovereign class disappear, with anyone present in those sections with it.
Chemahkuu is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 30 2013, 08:09 PM   #74
Timo
Admiral
 
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

Set Harth wrote: View Post
Timo wrote: View Post
But it is the content of the film.
No. "Nero destroys starships using red matter" is not the content of the film.
It's just about the only possible content of it, as Nero is shown incapable of destroying multiple starships by any other means.

Timo wrote:
No, when it is engaged in a desperate battle with a midget spacecraft a few seconds before the red matter detonation.
But you said it could offer no resistance to the Enterprise. Now it sounds like you're talking about the Jellyfish, which only gets close enough to ram Nero due to the Enterprise shooting down the missiles targeting it. We were told outright what would happen if several missiles hit the Enterprise.
In the "battle" with the Jellyfish, the Narada demonstrates it cannot threaten modern starships with its missiles at all. Sulu shoots down all of them with ease! Nero's only weapon is surprise, and utter devotion to crazy revenge. Wait, that's two weapons...

A threat in Klingon space, that they don't exactly have a mandate to go traipsing around in? That they wouldn't be expected to do anything about?
V'Ger toasted Klingon ships next door to Earth. That got a reaction. Why shouldn't this mysterious supership get the same treatment?

How does that in any way affect the Federation response at Vulcan, other than in needlessly running the risk that someone figures out the Vulcan situation is a trap?
Starfleet can't risk not sending everything it's got to stop the new menace. If it killed fifty Klingon ships, the only hope of stopping it starts at sending two hundred ships.

It doesn't look like it. That appears to be a bunch of ships shot up by missiles, not a bunch of ships sucked into a red matter black hole. When Vulcan was destroyed, or when the Narada was destroyed, they didn't leave "carnage" behind.
When the Narada was hit with the full might of the entire supply of red matter, she was twisted and shattered, with "carnage" in evidence, but with habitable spaces within still remaining. No different from what happened to those starships over Vulcan.

When Vulcan went, we were too far away to see what was left.

Timo wrote:
a move that doesn't work with surprise arrivals such as the delayed Enterprise.
Enterprise is really no more of a surprise arrival than the other ships, unless you think Nero can somehow precisely calculate Starfleet response time.
Why would he have any difficulty doing that? Starfleet is rushing towards Vulcan to help, obviously constantly sending messages to Nero that tell of their ETA...

The fleet arrives all at once, quite possibly plunging into a red matter minefield. There's no time to reset that minefield for the late arrival. But there's the shock and awe effect: Pike doesn't seem to think he could shoot down the incoming missiles, even though he has studied the Kelvin incident and learned that George Kirk did that just fine.

In the script, as opposed to the final version of the film, the timeline is different. The message about the Rura Penthe battle comes first, then the "lightning storm" of Spock's emergence. This shows that from the POV of the script the Narada was intended to be strong enough to destroy a Klingon armada without the red matter, and IMO it seems dubious to assume that the ship was rendered incapable of doing so just because the Rura Penthe scenes were deleted.
This is the logical consequence of the change - but not only that. It is also the logical consequence of the demonstrated weakness of the non-military mining rig in all onscreen combat. Together, these create consistency. Appealing to rejected story ideas creates inconsistency.

Timo Saloniemi
Timo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 30 2013, 08:17 PM   #75
King Daniel Into Darkness
Admiral
 
King Daniel Into Darkness's Avatar
 
Location: England again
Re: Dreadnought-Class Production Line (Spoilers?)

Narada was shooting cluster missiles at the Enterprise from a distance, giving them room to evade. One out of at least five missiles hit. The Vengeance was at point-blank range behind the Enterprise firing everything it had.

ID's attack certainly looked a lot more visceral and brutal.
__________________
Star Trek Imponderables, fun mashups of Trek's biggest continuity errors! Ep1, Ep2 and Ep3
King Daniel Into Darkness is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:17 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.