RSS iconTwitter iconFacebook icon

The Trek BBS title image

The Trek BBS statistics

Threads: 141,413
Posts: 5,506,313
Members: 25,129
Currently online: 488
Newest member: krishna

TrekToday headlines

Retro Review: The Emperor’s New Cloak
By: Michelle on Dec 20

Star Trek Opera
By: T'Bonz on Dec 19

New Abrams Project
By: T'Bonz on Dec 18

IDW Publishing March 2015 Comics
By: T'Bonz on Dec 17

Paramount Star Trek 3 Expectations
By: T'Bonz on Dec 17

Star Trek #39 Sneak Peek
By: T'Bonz on Dec 16

Star Trek 3 Potential Director Shortlist
By: T'Bonz on Dec 16

Official Starships Collection Update
By: T'Bonz on Dec 15

Retro Review: Prodigal Daughter
By: Michelle on Dec 13

Sindicate Lager To Debut In The US Next Week
By: T'Bonz on Dec 12


Welcome! The Trek BBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans. Please login to see our full range of forums as well as the ability to send and receive private messages, track your favourite topics and of course join in the discussions.

If you are a new visitor, join us for free. If you are an existing member please login below. Note: for members who joined under our old messageboard system, please login with your display name not your login name.


Go Back   The Trek BBS > Star Trek Movies > Star Trek Movies XI+

Star Trek Movies XI+ Discuss J.J. Abrams' rebooted Star Trek here.

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old December 18 2012, 04:13 PM   #1
Franklin
Rear Admiral
 
Location: In the bleachers
The Volcano Problem

What's below might be spoilerish if you haven't seen the first nine minutes or read a summary of them.













First, I don't know if Orci and Kurtzman meant it, but there's a neat parallel between what Spock is doing in the volcano and what Spock Prime's mission was.

Second, the whole thing is so wreckless, which I think it was supposed to be in order to show us how raw (and cocky) Kirk is as a commander. I can't imagine a 50-ish Kirk coming up with a plan like this. So, it's a good scene from that point, too.

That said, I do have a couple of nit-picky observations about the scene.

The shuttle may not have been built to withstand the heat inside a volcano for a long period of time, but Scotty tells Kirk that if the volcano blows, he's not sure the Enteprise itself can withstand the heat. Hmm. Lava is about 2000 degrees F. That's a little under the hottest temperatures reached on parts of the surface of the space shuttles when they re-entered the Earth's atmosphere. (The most insulating of the tiles were good up to about 2300 degrees F.) So, we're saying the tritanium outsides of a 23rd century starship are no better than 1970s technology at heat resistance? Even for short periods of time?

Sulu also says he's not sure he can maintain "that kind of altitude" over the volcano. So, after boldly going to the bottom of an ocean, Sulu thinks he can't hover the Enterprsie above a volcano for a few seconds to beam Spock out?

And again, the transporters are no good. Two movies, and two times the transporters couldn't be used when they'd have been most useful. I can see why McCoy never trusted the damn things.
__________________
Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect. -- Mark Twain
Franklin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 04:17 PM   #2
Timo
Admiral
 
Re: The Volcano Problem

I don't know what actually happens in the nine-minute spoiler thing, but I would imagine the volcanic thing is threatening the entire planet somehow - else why bother messing with it? That would mean things bigger than just "lava". If the eruption or whatever has global scope, odds are the starship might get buried under hot rock, the constant heat of which pressing against the (shieldless) hull (thousands of degrees Celsius) might indeed do a lot of damage.

As for hovering with a starship, I guess there are buffeting issues to be considered, something that would be absent underwater.

And I like the consistency in the transporters never working.

Timo Saloniemi
Timo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 04:19 PM   #3
Bishop76
Fleet Captain
 
Bishop76's Avatar
 
Location: Wisconsin
Re: The Volcano Problem

The shuttle problem seemed to be an intake problem - like it was sucking up too much ash. Which is a nitpicking problem in and of itself. Who knows - maybe the shuttles need air intake in atmospheric flight.
__________________
Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or fucking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.
Bishop76 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 04:23 PM   #4
Ovation
Vice Admiral
 
Location: La Belle Province or The Green Mountain State (depends on the day of the week)
Re: The Volcano Problem

Franklin wrote: View Post
What's below might be spoilerish if you haven't seen the first nine minutes or read a summary of them.













First, I don't know if Orci and Kurtzman meant it, but there's a neat parallel between what Spock is doing in the volcano and what Spock Prime's mission was.

Second, the whole thing is so wreckless, which I think it was supposed to be in order to show us how raw (and cocky) Kirk is as a commander. I can't imagine a 50-ish Kirk coming up with a plan like this. So, it's a good scene from that point, too.

That said, I do have a couple of nit-picky observations about the scene.

The shuttle may not have been built to withstand the heat inside a volcano for a long period of time, but Scotty tells Kirk that if the volcano blows, he's not sure the Enteprise itself can withstand the heat. Hmm. Lava is about 2000 degrees F. That's a little under the hottest temperatures reached on parts of the surface of the space shuttles when they re-entered the Earth's atmosphere. (The most insulating of the tiles were good up to about 2300 degrees F.) So, we're saying the tritanium outsides of a 23rd century starship are no better than 1970s technology at heat resistance? Even for short periods of time?

Sulu also says he's not sure he can maintain "that kind of altitude" over the volcano. So, after boldly going to the bottom of an ocean, Sulu thinks he can't hover the Enterprsie above a volcano for a few seconds to beam Spock out?

And again, the transporters are no good. Two movies, and two times the transporters couldn't be used when they'd have been most useful. I can see why McCoy never trusted the damn things.
Don't starships routinely rely on shields to diffuse heat? If so, would not lowering the shields to beam up Spock expose the ship to an unusual degree of heat? (just doing my best "geek" response here--I'm not up on "my technical manuals" like Scotty).

As for altitude, hovering might be quite a bit more difficult than simply submerging in water (where, again, shields and deflectors can help maintain position in the water), particularly if the volcanic explosions make the altitude variable, to some degree.

Anyway, I don't really try to reconcile such minute details all that often (it would make a lot of movies, not just Trek, become a lot of work instead of entertainment) but I am trying to avoid the pile of marking staring at me, so I thought I'd give it my best (uninformed) shot.
Ovation is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 05:26 PM   #5
DarthTom
Fleet Admiral
 
DarthTom's Avatar
 
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Re: The Volcano Problem

Ovation wrote: View Post
Don't starships routinely rely on shields to diffuse heat? If so, would not lowering the shields to beam up Spock expose the ship to an unusual degree of heat? (just doing my best "geek" response here--I'm not up on "my technical manuals" like Scotty).
Older Spock gave Scotty the calculations on how to transport at warp with the shield on, correct? So that would be irrelevant.
DarthTom is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 05:39 PM   #6
SalvorHardin
Rear Admiral
 
SalvorHardin's Avatar
 
Location: Star's End
Re: The Volcano Problem

DarthTom wrote: View Post
Older Spock gave Scotty the calculations on how to transport at warp with the shield on, correct?
Correct up until the transport at warp part.
Doing it while the shields are on wasn't mentioned as far as I can remember.
__________________

SalvorHardin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 05:53 PM   #7
Ovation
Vice Admiral
 
Location: La Belle Province or The Green Mountain State (depends on the day of the week)
Re: The Volcano Problem

DarthTom wrote: View Post
Ovation wrote: View Post
Don't starships routinely rely on shields to diffuse heat? If so, would not lowering the shields to beam up Spock expose the ship to an unusual degree of heat? (just doing my best "geek" response here--I'm not up on "my technical manuals" like Scotty).
Older Spock gave Scotty the calculations on how to transport at warp with the shield on, correct? So that would be irrelevant.
SalvorHardin wrote: View Post
DarthTom wrote: View Post
Older Spock gave Scotty the calculations on how to transport at warp with the shield on, correct?
Correct up until the transport at warp part.
Doing it while the shields are on wasn't mentioned as far as I can remember.
Don't remember a discussion of shields (I haven't watched the film as often as the TOS episodes, so I can't recall). However, it would not be the first time that a planet's natural environment somehow interfered with transporter technology, so if that's in play AND the shields are in place…voila--Orci's "the fans will reason it out" applies here.
Ovation is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 06:02 PM   #8
SalvorHardin
Rear Admiral
 
SalvorHardin's Avatar
 
Location: Star's End
Re: The Volcano Problem

Ovation wrote: View Post
DarthTom wrote: View Post
Ovation wrote: View Post
Don't starships routinely rely on shields to diffuse heat? If so, would not lowering the shields to beam up Spock expose the ship to an unusual degree of heat? (just doing my best "geek" response here--I'm not up on "my technical manuals" like Scotty).
Older Spock gave Scotty the calculations on how to transport at warp with the shield on, correct? So that would be irrelevant.
SalvorHardin wrote: View Post
DarthTom wrote: View Post
Older Spock gave Scotty the calculations on how to transport at warp with the shield on, correct?
Correct up until the transport at warp part.
Doing it while the shields are on wasn't mentioned as far as I can remember.
Don't remember a discussion of shields (I haven't watched the film as often as the TOS episodes, so I can't recall). However, it would not be the first time that a planet's natural environment somehow interfered with transporter technology, so if that's in play AND the shields are in place…voila--Orci's "the fans will reason it out" applies here.
I quickly rewatched the relevant scenes since my last post and didn't see any mention of shields.

In any case, the Narada was about to start drilling and wasn't threatened by anything so it probably had the shields down.
After all, the whole point of the Titan maneuver was to catch Nero with his pants down.
__________________

SalvorHardin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 06:08 PM   #9
Franklin
Rear Admiral
 
Location: In the bleachers
Re: The Volcano Problem

Ovation wrote: View Post

Don't starships routinely rely on shields to diffuse heat? If so, would not lowering the shields to beam up Spock expose the ship to an unusual degree of heat? (just doing my best "geek" response here--I'm not up on "my technical manuals" like Scotty).

As for altitude, hovering might be quite a bit more difficult than simply submerging in water (where, again, shields and deflectors can help maintain position in the water), particularly if the volcanic explosions make the altitude variable, to some degree.

Anyway, I don't really try to reconcile such minute details all that often (it would make a lot of movies, not just Trek, become a lot of work instead of entertainment) but I am trying to avoid the pile of marking staring at me, so I thought I'd give it my best (uninformed) shot.
Yeah. I don't mean to take it too seriously, myself. And yes, the Enterprise would have to be fully exposed to the elements (shields down) to beam Spock up.

In "Operation Annihilate!", as they chased the ship Denevan ship heading for the sun (shields up or not, it's not said), Spock says the hull temperature of the Enterprise is 480 degrees, then a few seconds later, it's 1000 (I looked that up, by the way, it was not in my head).
Since my oven can do 480 F, and since he says degrees (he wouldn't if it were the Kelvin scale), I'm assuming it's degrees Celsius. One thousand Celsius is almost 2000 degrees. So at least for a short time, the hull was withstanding that heat and probably a little more until Kirk finally ordered the ship to do a 180. In any case, 2000 degrees must be near the limit of hull tolerance. So in the nine minute clip, Scotty is erring on the side of caution.

As far as marking papers goes, any distraction from that is a good distraction.
__________________
Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect. -- Mark Twain
Franklin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 06:10 PM   #10
SalvorHardin
Rear Admiral
 
SalvorHardin's Avatar
 
Location: Star's End
Re: The Volcano Problem

Franklin wrote: View Post
So in the nine minute clip, Scotty is erring on the side of caution.
Plus, Mr Scott has been known to exaggerate a wee bit.
Got to maintain that miracle worker reputation after all. Or start building it in this universe
__________________

SalvorHardin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 18 2012, 06:14 PM   #11
Garak
Talk to me, like lovers do
 
Garak's Avatar
 
Location: Manticore can't handle me
Re: The Volcano Problem

Yeah....when I see the movie, this definitely won't bug me.
Garak is online now   Reply With Quote
Old December 19 2012, 03:44 PM   #12
JarodRussell
Vice Admiral
 
JarodRussell's Avatar
 
Re: The Volcano Problem

The nuEnterprise has the capabilities of plot. Underwater? No problem, because cool. Heat? A problem, because dramatic. And the transporters, which were previously able to transport across several astronomic units and faster than light, suddenly don't work here either. I guess if someone aboard uses a hairdryer, the transporters malfunction.

It also makes no sense to hide a space ship from indigenous javelin throwers under water instead of, like, I dunno, space.

A shuttle having an intake and/or an overheating problem is ridiculous.
JarodRussell is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 19 2012, 05:19 PM   #13
DarthTom
Fleet Admiral
 
DarthTom's Avatar
 
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Re: The Volcano Problem

JarodRussell wrote: View Post
The nuEnterprise has the capabilities of plot. Underwater? No problem, because cool. Heat? A problem, because dramatic. And the transporters, which were previously able to transport across several astronomic units and faster than light, suddenly don't work here either. I guess if someone aboard uses a hairdryer, the transporters malfunction.

It also makes no sense to hide a space ship from indigenous javelin throwers under water instead of, like, I dunno, space.

A shuttle having an intake and/or an overheating problem is ridiculous.
Meh. All of Trek has been guilty of that to a greater or lesser degree. Time travel is one of the most over used plot devices in all Trek lore. And lets not forget the Borg - once a huge menance now are easily defeated by just Voyager.

Then there is the magical engineering solution of the week only to be forgotten about just two episodes later when a like problem arises. There are too many to mention but just off the top of my head one would be armband transporter devices oh and personal shields created on the holodeck by worf simply using his communicator.

J.J. is no more or no less guilty of using plot devices for dramatic effect and/or as a lazy writing to circumnavigate a problem then they did in TNG, DS9, Enterprise and all the other films.

Oh, and lets not forget when Janeway and Paris go to every part of the universe - DE-evolve - mate -and then are reanimated.

Or in Star Trek V when in a matter of a few hours the Enterprise travels to the center of the galaxy to do battle with God.
DarthTom is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 19 2012, 06:30 PM   #14
BillJ
Admiral
 
BillJ's Avatar
 
Location: Covington, Ky.
View BillJ's Twitter Profile
Re: The Volcano Problem

JarodRussell wrote: View Post

It also makes no sense to hide a space ship from indigenous javelin throwers under water instead of, like, I dunno, space.
I'm really hoping they have a good reason for the Enterprise to be hiding underwater.
__________________
"...the most elementary and valuable statement in science, the beginning of wisdom, is I do not know." - Lt. Commander Data, "Where Silence Has Lease"
BillJ is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 19 2012, 07:50 PM   #15
UssGlenn
Captain
 
UssGlenn's Avatar
 
Location: New Orleans, LA
Re: The Volcano Problem

The calculations Spock prime used to modify the transporters were used on the shuttle on delta Vega. Scotty looked at them but didn't write them down. If Spock decided to erase them, or the transporter doesn't save that sort of input, after Kirk and Scotty beamed out, it might take Scotty quite some time to redevelop them.
__________________
"What are you going to do?"
"I don't know. I'm making this up as I go."
UssGlenn is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:14 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.