I remember the rumors after season 1 of a Roanoke colony season. I still think that would be pretty awesome.
Slightly off topic but I'm currently rewatching Season 1, 8/12 episodes in. I find it weird how they cast Eric Close to play Constance's former husband, and yet he's only in 2 episodes, and in those he's in each ep for about 10 seconds. I know he's a not super duper huge star, but he's a well established actor, the lead in at least two old favourite shows of mine I used to love (albeit both one season wonders.) It's odd why they didn't do more with him.
The story surrounds a young farm boy who joins the carnival in search of meaning to his life and their ultimate battle against the forces of evil led by a supposed holy man posessed by demons, who controls his followers through his sermons heard on national radio... Oh wait... Dang...