RSS iconTwitter iconFacebook icon

The Trek BBS title image

The Trek BBS statistics

Threads: 138,935
Posts: 5,389,997
Members: 24,724
Currently online: 492
Newest member: shrivishk

TrekToday headlines

New Trek-themed Bobble Heads
By: T'Bonz on Aug 21

IDW Publishing November Trek Comic
By: T'Bonz on Aug 20

Pegg/Wright Trilogy In The Works
By: T'Bonz on Aug 20

Star Trek: The Compendium Rebate Details
By: T'Bonz on Aug 20

Gold Key Archives Volume 2
By: T'Bonz on Aug 19

Takei Documentary Wins Award
By: T'Bonz on Aug 19

Cumberbatch To Voice Khan
By: T'Bonz on Aug 19

Shaun And Ed On Phineas and Ferb
By: T'Bonz on Aug 18

New Ships Coming From Official Starships Collection
By: T'Bonz on Aug 18

Trek Stars Take On Ice Bucket Challenge
By: T'Bonz on Aug 18


Welcome! The Trek BBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans. Please login to see our full range of forums as well as the ability to send and receive private messages, track your favourite topics and of course join in the discussions.

If you are a new visitor, join us for free. If you are an existing member please login below. Note: for members who joined under our old messageboard system, please login with your display name not your login name.


Go Back   The Trek BBS > Star Trek TV Series > Enterprise

Enterprise The final frontier has a new beginning in this forum!

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old July 9 2013, 03:33 AM   #1
Captain Kathryn
Commodore
 
Captain Kathryn's Avatar
 
Location: In Star Trek / Doctor Who fantasy land aka New Jersey
Send a message via Windows Live Messenger to Captain Kathryn
Similitude vs. Tuvix

A lot of people condemn Janeway for separating Tuvix, but what Archer did in "Similitude" doesn't seem to be that different on a basic level. The only differences seem to be that, on ENT, there was a desperate situation involved and that Archer CHOSE to create the cloned copy of Trip in order to save him. In a way, one could argue that in and of itself that act was immoral. Creating a life that is destined to soon die to save another. At least Janeway did not CHOOSE to combine Tuvok and and Neelix. It was an accident.

That said, the main difference is that at the end, the Sim chose death to save Trip in a way that Tuvix didn't choose death to save Tuvok and Neelix. Sim knew there was a possible cure that would allow him to live longer, but the consequence would be that Trip would die in result. However, Sim's death was more of a "true death" in the sense that at the end, they had a dead body. Also the circumstances surrounding Sim's creation and death were darker and shadier than on Tuvix because creating him was deliberate. They must have known that the Sim would not take kindly to being created in a lab, being forced to work, and then to die shortly after.

What do you guys think? Which was worse?

I don't mean to be starting another "Tuvix thread".

Just wondering which circumstance seemed "worse" to you?
Obviously neither situation was even close to ideal...
__________________
Assimilate more Janeway...among other stuff! Captain Kathryn's Tumblr

Last edited by Captain Kathryn; July 9 2013 at 03:48 AM.
Captain Kathryn is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 03:56 AM   #2
R. Star
Rear Admiral
 
R. Star's Avatar
 
Location: Shangri-La
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

The fundamental difference is Sim in the end however reluctantly did volunteer for the procedure. Tuvix didn't and was killed against his will.

Really the big ethical dilemma to me is what gave them the right to "grow" a sentient being for the sole purpose of harvesting it? But hey, small change compared to the genocide that is Dear Doctor.
__________________
"I was never a Star Trek fan." J.J. Abrams
R. Star is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 04:01 AM   #3
Captain Kathryn
Commodore
 
Captain Kathryn's Avatar
 
Location: In Star Trek / Doctor Who fantasy land aka New Jersey
Send a message via Windows Live Messenger to Captain Kathryn
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

R. Star wrote: View Post
The fundamental difference is Sim in the end however reluctantly did volunteer for the procedure. Tuvix didn't and was killed against his will.

Really the big ethical dilemma to me is what gave them the right to "grow" a sentient being for the sole purpose of harvesting it? But hey, small change compared to the genocide that is Dear Doctor.
That was my quandary.

ENT has one thing going for it in that Sim CHOSE to die.

But, what it has going AGAINST it is that...they created the being on purpose, deliberately in the first place...at least Tuvix was an accident.

So I don't know which is worse, honestly.
__________________
Assimilate more Janeway...among other stuff! Captain Kathryn's Tumblr
Captain Kathryn is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 04:09 AM   #4
R. Star
Rear Admiral
 
R. Star's Avatar
 
Location: Shangri-La
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

It was a good episode in a morbid kind of way just like Tuvix and the similarities are there to be certain. It was a good scene when Sim said "you're not a murderer" and Archer asked him not to make him one. But really by the time Sim was created he was one. He made Sim to save Trip's life. That's supposed to be his whole reason for existing. So either way he's already played god and one of them's gonna die and Archer -was- a murderer by that point.

And our dear Doctor Phlox conveniently keeps to himself that he can extend Sim's lifespan because well... that will keep him from helping out. At least Janeway was honest about what she did. She killed Tuvix because she liked Tuvok and Neelix more. The fact that Kes crying over Neelix persuaded her is proof of that. This crew... really shied away from the issue.
__________________
"I was never a Star Trek fan." J.J. Abrams
R. Star is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 04:14 AM   #5
Third Nacelle
Captain
 
Third Nacelle's Avatar
 
Location: The Denorios Belt
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

By sheer coincidence I first saw Similitude around the same time that I first read Never Let Me Go. In that book, clones are raised knowing when they grow up their organs will be harvested to save "real" people. They just go along with it, because that's just how it is and they've been raised to believe that's their purpose.

You can say it made a difference because Sim chose to die to save Trip, but did he really? Weren't they sort of prodding him toward that choice his entire life?

I can't see how it's ethical to create and kill one sentient being to save another, even if that being does go along with it.
Third Nacelle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 04:16 AM   #6
AllStarEntprise
Fleet Captain
 
AllStarEntprise's Avatar
 
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

Tuvix was worse. Transporter accident created a new life from two individuals. They should've accepted this change (Federation Principles after all) and not pursued the course of separating them in to two individuals again.

With Sim it wasn't just his life that was at stake at being lost it was Trip's. It's reminiscent of the movie "The Island" with Ewan McGregor and Scarlett Johansson. Clones were created by the wealthy and their bodies, and organs were used for a multitude of purposes should their original need them. However Sim only had a short life expectancy to begin with. It's not like "The Island" where the clones were capable of living full lives. Sim had weeks if not months to live a full life before he would expire. I can understand the logic behind it. It's similar to what we have today with organ cloning and transplants. Sim just happened to have a mind and could think and make decisions. If he hadn't he would be no different than a cloned liver that would be transplanted into an alcoholic who has used and abused their original liver.

Not squeaky clean but given Archer's situation I think he was justified to allow Pholox the go ahead with the cloning. Had Sim not volunteered or ran away like he planned then Trip would've died and Sim would've have also.
AllStarEntprise is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 12:17 PM   #7
teacake
Admiral
 
teacake's Avatar
 
Location: Militant Janeway True Path Devotees Compound. With Sehlats.
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

Wasn't Sim doomed to die soon? As in, a use by date?
__________________

"Damnit Spock. God damnit!" Kirk ST:V
■ ■ ■
Janeway does Melbourne
teacake is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 01:13 PM   #8
Infern0
Captain
 
Infern0's Avatar
 
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

If I recall, Archer did say that if they were in peacetime he would consider the option to try and save Sim but he didn't have that choice because the entire planet was at stake and he couldn't complete the mission without Trip, it was a case of the needs of the many...

BTW, simmilitude was a much better episode, than Tuvix. I actually shed a tear haha
Infern0 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 01:19 PM   #9
Infern0
Captain
 
Infern0's Avatar
 
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

teacake wrote: View Post
Wasn't Sim doomed to die soon? As in, a use by date?
Phlox had some experimental procedure that he thought might have been able to extend sims life
Infern0 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 9 2013, 04:27 PM   #10
Bukiyo
Lieutenant Commander
 
Bukiyo's Avatar
 
Location: New York
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

I think everyone is forgetting that when the decision to make Sim was made, Phlox thought he could harvest the parts needed without killing Sim. So they would have Trip and a copy of Trip with a short life span running around. After Sim grew up Phlox realized the procedure would kill Sim. I don't think the decision to make Sim was morally wrong, it's no different than parents who have another child to use the stem cells from the placenta to cure an already sick child they have. What unfortunately happened was that it turned out the surgery would kill Sim. That's when the dilemma came in. Well, and the dilemma that Sim only had a 15 day life span, but whose to say that's better or worse than being a slug in a jar.

(Not going to even touch Tuvix.)
Bukiyo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 10 2013, 07:46 AM   #11
HopefulRomantic
Phloxist Moderator
 
HopefulRomantic's Avatar
 
Location: feeding the cats again
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

Bukiyo wrote: View Post
I think everyone is forgetting that when the decision to make Sim was made, Phlox thought he could harvest the parts needed without killing Sim. So they would have Trip and a copy of Trip with a short life span running around. After Sim grew up Phlox realized the procedure would kill Sim. I don't think the decision to make Sim was morally wrong, it's no different than parents who have another child to use the stem cells from the placenta to cure an already sick child they have. What unfortunately happened was that it turned out the surgery would kill Sim. That's when the dilemma came in. Well, and the dilemma that Sim only had a 15 day life span, but whose to say that's better or worse than being a slug in a jar.

(Not going to even touch Tuvix.)
^^ This, all of this, I agree. You covered everything I was thinking to mention as I read through this thread.

I only saw "Tuvix" once. The ending made me very uncomfortable, and I've not sought it out to watch since. I've seen "Similitude" more times than I can count, and loved it every time. Both episodes have that classic-Trek "impossible dilemma" storyline, but "Similitude" drew me in without putting me off--perhaps because Sim chose to sacrifice his life to save Trip and help save the world. And because you could literally see the toll the situation was taking on Archer, as he grew more haggard with each passing day. And Phlox being the surrogate father who has to perform the surgery on his "son." And Sim's unfettered, unrequited feelings for T'Pol. And Sim petting Porthos at the end. It just destroyed me. Beautifully done, heartbreaking. One of my top 3 episodes of Enterprise.
__________________
"It's late, I'm tired, and there's so much left to do." ~Ernst Stavro Blofeld, Diamonds Are Forever
HopefulRomantic is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 10 2013, 08:28 AM   #12
Mach5
Rear Admiral
 
Mach5's Avatar
 
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

Tuvix was just Tuvok contaminated with all the Neelix's repulsiveness.

God, my disappointment when furball survived the separation process...

On the other hand, Sim was a compelling, likable character, and his death was tragic despite being necessary and unavoidable.
__________________
"Religion is something left over from the infancy of our intelligence, it will fade away as we adopt reason and science as our guidelines."
― Bertrand Russell
Mach5 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 11 2013, 12:12 AM   #13
Melakon
Vice Admiral
 
Melakon's Avatar
 
Location: Unmarked grave, Ekos
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

I think "Similitude" did a much better job of touching on the similar ethical problems than "Tuvix". And Sim was a more heroic character when it came to accepting the inevitable. Though it might have been sort of interesting if they had let Trip die and a long-life Sim had to take his place.
__________________
Moe: I'll take the blonde!
Larry: I'll take the brunette!
Curly: I'll take the Black and Tan!
--Wee Wee Monsieur (1938)
Melakon is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 11 2013, 10:32 PM   #14
Silvio Dante
Ensign
 
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

Infern0 wrote: View Post
If I recall, Archer did say that if they were in peacetime he would consider the option to try and save Sim but he didn't have that choice because the entire planet was at stake and he couldn't complete the mission without Trip, it was a case of the needs of the many...

BTW, simmilitude was a much better episode, than Tuvix. I actually shed a tear haha
I shed more than one

I don't remember the Tuvix episode to comment on it.

However the Similtude creation was done for the greater good. Also his natural lifespan was going to be 15 days. Phlox genuinely thought they could operate without it resulting in Sim's death...
Silvio Dante is offline   Reply With Quote
Old July 12 2013, 12:16 AM   #15
Captain Kathryn
Commodore
 
Captain Kathryn's Avatar
 
Location: In Star Trek / Doctor Who fantasy land aka New Jersey
Send a message via Windows Live Messenger to Captain Kathryn
Re: Similitude vs. Tuvix

Mach5 wrote: View Post
Tuvix was just Tuvok contaminated with all the Neelix's repulsiveness.

God, my disappointment when furball survived the separation process...

On the other hand, Sim was a compelling, likable character, and his death was tragic despite being necessary and unavoidable.
I take it you're not a fan of Neelix?
__________________
Assimilate more Janeway...among other stuff! Captain Kathryn's Tumblr
Captain Kathryn is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:36 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.