La-La Land Records to release 4-disc DS9 soundtrack set! - Page 16

Phily B · February 27 2013, 12:21 PM

the status seems stuck on will dispatch in 2-3 days for ten days now...

EDIT - I actually got it this morning, haha.

doubleohfive · February 27 2013, 06:58 PM

RandyS wrote:

asp7485 wrote:

dub wrote:

I think my favorite is the fourth CD plus the music from "The Visitor" (LOVE it)!

I agree, I like the 4th CD best. As it features more complete scores, it has a really nice flow. It's also the most thematic with lots of good uses of the DS9 theme and the original Star Trek theme. McCarthy's ability to blend the TOS theme and "The Way You Look Tonight" into the DS9 theme is pretty impressive. I really enjoy that montage cue from "What You Leave Behind." I think it may be up there with the all time great Trek music cues. I initially found the saxophone a bit jarring, but after a few listens, I enjoy it and wish it hasn't been dialed out of the final mix.

Yeah, the final montage cue IS good, but I have to admit that I'm disapointed that the TV version was not included in the set. I REALLY liked that. What we got on the CD wasn't bad, but the TV version is preferred.

At least for me.

The TV version has been available (and, for YEARS at that) over at TrekCore and on other fan sites.

Why would La-La Land waste valuable disc space on something that's been around for free for years?

Enterpriserules · February 27 2013, 07:22 PM

doubleohfive wrote:

RandyS wrote:

asp7485 wrote:

I agree, I like the 4th CD best. As it features more complete scores, it has a really nice flow. It's also the most thematic with lots of good uses of the DS9 theme and the original Star Trek theme. McCarthy's ability to blend the TOS theme and "The Way You Look Tonight" into the DS9 theme is pretty impressive. I really enjoy that montage cue from "What You Leave Behind." I think it may be up there with the all time great Trek music cues. I initially found the saxophone a bit jarring, but after a few listens, I enjoy it and wish it hasn't been dialed out of the final mix.

Yeah, the final montage cue IS good, but I have to admit that I'm disapointed that the TV version was not included in the set. I REALLY liked that. What we got on the CD wasn't bad, but the TV version is preferred.

At least for me.

The TV version has been available (and, for YEARS at that) over at TrekCore and on other fan sites.

Why would La-La Land waste valuable disc space on something that's been around for free for years?

I have to say I love those cues on the set, they are beautifully written and performed

Muldfeld · February 28 2013, 05:52 AM

timtonruben359 wrote:

Just wanted to see if anyone who ordered the CDs from Canada have got them yet? I checked my status last week and as of last Tuesday it says arrived in Canada at customs for processing. Just wanted to see.

I got my copy on Monday and I live in a major Canadian city. I hope you get yours soon.

Section 31 1/2 · February 28 2013, 06:06 AM

Muldfeld wrote:

timtonruben359 wrote:

Just wanted to see if anyone who ordered the CDs from Canada have got them yet? I checked my status last week and as of last Tuesday it says arrived in Canada at customs for processing. Just wanted to see.

I got my copy on Monday and I live in a major Canadian city. I hope you get yours soon.

I got mine today and I live in St Catharines just outside Niagara Falls, Ontario.

Spent some time with it. I enjoy it far more than the TNG set that's for sure.

The McCarthy disc is solid. I must say I was also quite surprised to hear the electric guitar on "Charge" from Shattered Mirror. More evidence of interesting music getting mixed down or completely out in the final episode edits.

On Disc two I very much dig the latter portion of the disc with Call to Arms being one of the highlights of the entire 4 disc set. Everything from Call to Arms on is solid. The By Inferno's Light and Broken Link cues are curious as to why they were included.

Disc 3 is all over the map. David Bell's music worked great with the show but on this disc it really highlights how repetitive of a composer he was. While Paul Baillargeon seems to have the opposite effect with me. I absolutely could not stand his music with the episodes and felt often times they ruined certain scenes but for some reason I really dig all of his tracks by themselves. Also, Greg Smith's Field of Fire and The Assignment are both standouts.

On Disc 4 I really dig Our Man Bashir and What You Leave Behind quite a bit. I can take or leave Trials and Tribble-ations."

RandyS · February 28 2013, 02:59 PM

doubleohfive wrote:

RandyS wrote:

asp7485 wrote:

I agree, I like the 4th CD best. As it features more complete scores, it has a really nice flow. It's also the most thematic with lots of good uses of the DS9 theme and the original Star Trek theme. McCarthy's ability to blend the TOS theme and "The Way You Look Tonight" into the DS9 theme is pretty impressive. I really enjoy that montage cue from "What You Leave Behind." I think it may be up there with the all time great Trek music cues. I initially found the saxophone a bit jarring, but after a few listens, I enjoy it and wish it hasn't been dialed out of the final mix.

Yeah, the final montage cue IS good, but I have to admit that I'm disapointed that the TV version was not included in the set. I REALLY liked that. What we got on the CD wasn't bad, but the TV version is preferred.

At least for me.

The TV version has been available (and, for YEARS at that) over at TrekCore and on other fan sites.

Why would La-La Land waste valuable disc space on something that's been around for free for years?

I don't know. Maybe because I didn't know it was there?

Tosk · February 28 2013, 03:06 PM

doubleohfive wrote:

Why would La-La Land waste valuable disc space on something that's been around for free for years?

Because that file is nothing but a straight rip right from the DVD. I don't think it's out of line to wish we could have had the cue on the CD properly.

[That said, I am super happy with what we did get.

]

Phily B · February 28 2013, 05:57 PM

I really like it

It was a pain to rip and rename all the tracks though..

doubleohfive · February 28 2013, 06:34 PM

Tosk wrote:

doubleohfive wrote:

Why would La-La Land waste valuable disc space on something that's been around for free for years?

Because that file is nothing but a straight rip right from the DVD. I don't think it's out of line to wish we could have had the cue on the CD properly.

[That said, I am super happy with what we did get.

]

Having the "What You Leave Behind" theme (DVD rip or not) available for so long is probably what led to the decision to not include it on the set. The other version was something most of us hadn't heard before. Or, it could be Dennis McCarthy himself wanted the version on the album for his own reasons. Who knows? The mere point I was trying to make was that if you really want the as aired version, it's out there.

Enterpriserules · February 28 2013, 07:30 PM

doubleohfive wrote:

Tosk wrote:

doubleohfive wrote:

Why would La-La Land waste valuable disc space on something that's been around for free for years?

Because that file is nothing but a straight rip right from the DVD. I don't think it's out of line to wish we could have had the cue on the CD properly.

[That said, I am super happy with what we did get.

]

Having the "What You Leave Behind" theme (DVD rip or not) available for so long is probably what led to the decision to not include it on the set. The other version was something most of us hadn't heard before. Or, it could be Dennis McCarthy himself wanted the version on the album for his own reasons. Who knows? The mere point I was trying to make was that if you really want the as aired version, it's out there.

Honestly I think that this version on the album is really good and I am glad that they gave it to us.

Tosk · March 1 2013, 04:02 AM

doubleohfive wrote:

Having the "What You Leave Behind" theme (DVD rip or not) available for so long is probably what led to the decision to not include it on the set.

I doubt it. There are four versions of the DS9 main titles on the new CD release, and at least three of them have been available for years on official CDs. It's surely a decision to present the cue as composed rather than the altered version used in the final edit.

I don't personally have a problem with the omission/decision, I just don't think that someone who wishes it was on there is wrong to do so.

Christopher · March 1 2013, 04:17 AM

Tosk wrote:

It's surely a decision to present the cue as composed rather than the altered version used in the final edit.

Which, in my experience, is the normal practice for soundtrack albums. The whole point of them is to present the music in its pure form, in a way it couldn't be heard in the final film or episode. Using a version that's different from what's in the show isn't making a mistake, it's revealing something new.

Tosk · March 1 2013, 10:12 AM

Not that anyone said it was a mistake, of course.

Phily B · March 1 2013, 10:38 AM

Enterpriserules wrote:

doubleohfive wrote:

Tosk wrote:

Because that file is nothing but a straight rip right from the DVD. I don't think it's out of line to wish we could have had the cue on the CD properly.

[That said, I am super happy with what we did get.

]

Having the "What You Leave Behind" theme (DVD rip or not) available for so long is probably what led to the decision to not include it on the set. The other version was something most of us hadn't heard before. Or, it could be Dennis McCarthy himself wanted the version on the album for his own reasons. Who knows? The mere point I was trying to make was that if you really want the as aired version, it's out there.

Honestly I think that this version on the album is really good and I am glad that they gave it to us.

RT

Muldfeld · March 1 2013, 10:38 AM

[QUOTE=doubleohfive;7739764]

RandyS wrote:

Why would La-La Land waste valuable disc space on something that's been around for free for years?

Have you heard the work La La Land did on "The X-Files: Volume One" set? They mislabelled the theme music on various CDs as being from seasons from which they actually weren't, and just reused the same theme from a given season more than once.

"A Synopsis and Release" from the episode "Release" is in terrible sound quality with static and high-pitched humming all over. When I asked that this be corrected, La La Land refused to look into it and kind of threatened me to shut up about it.

La La Land can do some terrible work.

February 27 2013, 12:21 PM	#226
Phily B Fleet Captain Location: United Kingdom	Re: La-La Land Records to release 4-disc DS9 soundtrack set! the status seems stuck on will dispatch in 2-3 days for ten days now... EDIT - I actually got it this morning, haha. Last edited by Phily B; February 27 2013 at 03:14 PM.

February 28 2013, 05:57 PM	#233
Phily B Fleet Captain Location: United Kingdom	Re: La-La Land Records to release 4-disc DS9 soundtrack set! I really like it It was a pain to rip and rename all the tracks though..

March 1 2013, 10:12 AM	#238
Tosk Rear Admiral Location: On the run.	Re: La-La Land Records to release 4-disc DS9 soundtrack set! Not that anyone said it was a mistake, of course.

STAR TREK

CSI

ABOUT US