Canon characters killed in lit-verse. (spoilers)

[Sci]

Edit_XYZ wrote:

---

Sci

My first post on this thread should make it clear that it is a tangent on the threat title (one of many previous ones, in this forum).
If you have a problem with this - you must have a problem with a LOT of threads here.

It's more than just a tangent -- it comes straight out of nowhere and has nothing whatsoever to do with the topic at hand. I don't understand why you're bringing up the question of what aspects of books from authors who are "on the out" might be contradicted here instead of the actual threads dedicated to the topic of authors being on the out.

It's the equivalent of bringing up the new James Bond movie in a thread about Les Misérables but ignoring the actual Skyfall thread.

[JD]

EDIT: Sci's right, and since I've remembered how pointless it is to argue with you I'm done.

[Edit_XYZ]

Sci wrote:

---

It's more than just a tangent -- it comes straight out of nowhere and has nothing whatsoever to do with the topic at hand. I don't understand why you're bringing up the question of what aspects of books from authors who are "on the out" might be contradicted here instead of the actual threads dedicated to the topic of authors being on the out.

It's the equivalent of bringing up the new James Bond movie in a thread about Les Misérables but ignoring the actual Skyfall thread.

So - talking about the future alive/dead prospects of a canon character is not a tangent - indeed, exactly on the subject of this thread for you, yes, Sci?
OK.

[JD]

I want to apologize for my lack of self control and dragging this thread farther off topic than it should have gotten. Sorry.

[Sci]

So, Jaresh-Inyo died in Articles. And of course, McCoy died in Crucible.

[Edit_XYZ]

JD
Read the post I already repeated once. And then the thread you claim to know.

Also, you went from "we don't know for a fact that that is why they chose to ignore IFM" to "All we know for sure is that instead of trying to explain away the stuff with Ogawa, Barclar, and the La Forge/Brahms pairing they decided to ignore them." in the same post.
'don't know for a fact' and 'we know for sure' are contradictory, JD.

Your 'see no evil hear no evil speak no evil' just went into high gear.
Who are you trying to convince, JD? Yourself?

[Sci]

Oh! I forgot -- Amanda Greyson was killed in Crucible: Spock - The Fire and the Rose.

[King Daniel Into Darkness]

Sci wrote:

---

Oh! I forgot -- Amanda Greyson was killed in Crucible: Spock - The Fire and the Rose.

Her second Treklit demise, after Ann Crispin's Sarek.

Oh, and Trelane died in Peter David's Q-Squared.

[Sci]

Kieran Duffy was killed in SCE: Wildfire by David Mack.

[JD]

Ke Hovath from DS9's "The Storyteller" died in "Fragments and Omens".

[Paris]

If memory serves, Katherine Janeway died in PAD's Before Dishonor

[T'Bonz]

BillJ wrote:

---

Those books are eight years old at this point.

While it's nice to include a spoiler, it's not mandatory after this length of time.

(I'm one of the mods in here now, BTW.)

[Therin of Andor]

Edit_XYZ wrote:

---

These elements were already used by other authors before the new editorial regime

Ed S. has been part of the "Star Trek" editorial team for many years. He edited numerous "New Frontier" novels while Marco was busy with DS9 and Margaret was concentrating on non fiction tie-ins.

[lvsxy808]

JD wrote:

---

Ke Hovath from DS9's "The Storyteller" died in "Fragments and Omens".

Minor nitpick - that scene was actually in The Soul Key. He first reappeared in F&O, though.

.

[Greg Cox]

Therin of Andor wrote:

---

Ed S. has been part of the "Star Trek" editorial team for many years. He edited numerous "New Frontier" novels while Marco was busy with DS9 and Margaret was concentrating on non fiction tie-ins.

For the record, Ed has been editing Star Trek novels since at least 2005. He took over editing my Khan books after John Ordover departed. So he's not exactly "new."