What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? - Page 2

ssosmcin · June 11 2012, 06:06 PM

Tiberius wrote:

sbk1234 wrote:

Tiberius wrote:

The amount of damage Voyager took in year of hell (it was destroyed) and the length of time it endured before being destroyed (a whole year, or thereabouts) means that Voyager wins this poll easily.

Does the matter that that all happened in an alternate time line affect this result at all?

It was on screen, so I count it.

The reset button erasing the previous year and everything that happened to Voyager was also on screen. That damage never actually happened. Year of Hell should then be disqualified.

Satyrquaze · June 11 2012, 06:08 PM

Gotta give it to the Enterprise-E. She rammed the Scimitar and survived after taking a hell of a beating.

Voyager got destroyed and (yet another) reset button at the end of "Year of Hell" and that disqualifies her from this.

Tom · June 11 2012, 06:24 PM

The 1701-A was not in ST:TWOK or ST:TSFS as pointed out by the OP and another poster.

OmahaStar · June 11 2012, 06:34 PM

ngc7293 wrote:

I haven't voted in part because of several ships
The Enterprise C was utterly destroyed in battle. Since someone pointed out that the original Defiant was destroyed and no one said no to that, What about the C?

We don't really know that. All we know is that it was captured by the Romulans. How (or if) it was really destroyed, we don't know, since the only person we've heard talk about it is a half-Romulan who is already angry at Starfleet.

Then there is the first 1701-A in ST-III where the ship was taken over by Klingons and then blown up by kirk. Does that meet the criteria?

Nope. Since the first 1701-A did not appear until the next movie, The Voyage Home.

Last is the destruction of ENT-D. I forgot the movie. Everyone had enough time to get to the saucer to separate. Given the cercumstances the D had to go thru, I would think it would satisfy the criteria.

Yes, the Enterprise-D was destroyed by "a 20 year old Klingon ship" but what people keep forgetting (or not mentioning) is that those Klingons had the access codes to the Enterprise's shields and took them down, just as the Enterprise had done to the Relient back in Star Trek II. There's a reason they keep the shields up when they're in battle.

I know the Ent-C isn't a hero ship, just as the Ent-B isn't a hero ship even though the latter appeared in a movie helmed Captain Sulu.

No, it didn't. That was Captain Harriman. The Sulu who was piloting the Enterprise-B was Demora Sulu - Captain Sulu's daughter.

Did you get a single fact right?

Rarewolf · June 11 2012, 07:31 PM

Satyrquaze wrote:

Gotta give it to the Enterprise-E. She rammed the Scimitar and survived after taking a hell of a beating.

Voyager got destroyed and (yet another) reset button at the end of "Year of Hell" and that disqualifies her from this.

She got a fair beating, bridge evacuated and hull breaches in Deadlock.

Satyrquaze · June 12 2012, 05:16 PM

^ The Enterprise-D has that beat with "Yesterday's Enterprise".

barnaclelapse · June 13 2012, 01:43 AM

Well, good to know I'm not the only weirdo who picked D.

BK613 · June 13 2012, 02:06 AM

"One Seven Oh One. No bloody A, B, C, or D." (or E)
oh wait, not on the list!?

junxon · June 13 2012, 02:22 AM

i want to vote for ent C. that took the most pounding. end of. also her captain had the most segmented neck of any starfleet captain ever. seriously watch yesterdays enterprise and try not to stare at her neck!

Knight Templar · June 13 2012, 04:49 AM

Too bad we couldn't vote for the Oberth class.

Those ships were pure death traps.

jpch · June 13 2012, 08:35 PM

Knight Templar wrote:

Too bad we couldn't vote for the Oberth class.

Those ships were pure death traps.

Lol XD

Ethros · June 13 2012, 10:49 PM

NX-01 obvs, late Season 3 anyone?

Complete with those poor crew members going for a ride

Knight Templar · June 13 2012, 11:11 PM

If I had served on the NX-01 Enterprise I think I would've eaten, worked, and slept in a spacesuit.

jpch · June 14 2012, 09:13 AM

Knight Templar wrote:

If I had served on the NX-01 Enterprise I think I would've eaten, worked, and slept in a spacesuit.

ahahahahaha

SilentP · June 15 2012, 08:02 PM

I vote for the NX for the above photo's reason. That and the fact that it couldn't replicate replacement parts like the others. Also doesn't help that the ship was essentially the first of a new generation of human starships (not just a new class like Voyager and the Defiant was, but a whole new level of ship capability) so the technology only has a few years of familiarity to it's engineers (skilled though they are).

View Poll Results: Wich Ship displayed largest amount of endurance and defensive ability?
USS Enterprise-E	13	27.08%
USS Voyager	17	35.42%
USS Defiant	13	27.08%
USS Enterprise -D	3	6.25%
USS Enterprise-A	3	6.25%
USS Enterprise-NX	8	16.67%
USS Enterprise-jj abrams	0	0%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 48. You may not vote on this poll

June 11 2012, 06:08 PM	#17
Satyrquaze The finest Vice Admiral in the fleet Location: Satyrquaze	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? Gotta give it to the Enterprise-E. She rammed the Scimitar and survived after taking a hell of a beating. Voyager got destroyed and (yet another) reset button at the end of "Year of Hell" and that disqualifies her from this. __________________ “If at first you don't succeed, cheat, repeat until caught, then lie.” -Anomymous Last edited by Satyrquaze; June 11 2012 at 06:26 PM.

June 11 2012, 06:24 PM	#18
Tom Rear Admiral Location: In your Mind!	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? The 1701-A was not in ST:TWOK or ST:TSFS as pointed out by the OP and another poster. __________________ Make it so...

June 12 2012, 05:16 PM	#21
Satyrquaze The finest Vice Admiral in the fleet Location: Satyrquaze	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? ^ The Enterprise-D has that beat with "Yesterday's Enterprise". __________________ “If at first you don't succeed, cheat, repeat until caught, then lie.” -Anomymous

June 13 2012, 01:43 AM	#22
barnaclelapse Commodore Location: Waverly, VA.	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? Well, good to know I'm not the only weirdo who picked D. __________________ http://drunkmonkeys.onimpression.com/ www.mpjournal.com Tumblr: http://barnaclelapse.tumblr.com Word Press: http://gabrielricard.wordpress.com

STAR TREK

CSI

ABOUT US

June 13 2012, 02:06 AM	#23
BK613 Captain Location: BK613	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? "One Seven Oh One. No bloody A, B, C, or D." (or E) oh wait, not on the list!? __________________ ------------------- "The single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has taken place." - George Bernard Shaw

June 13 2012, 02:22 AM	#24
junxon Fleet Captain Location: I'm a Romulan now. Romulans are cool	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? i want to vote for ent C. that took the most pounding. end of. also her captain had the most segmented neck of any starfleet captain ever. seriously watch yesterdays enterprise and try not to stare at her neck! __________________ I'm your Venus, I'm your fire, At your desire, Captain. - Mr Spock Hello to Jason Isaacs!

June 13 2012, 04:49 AM	#25
Knight Templar Commodore Location: Oklahoma	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? Too bad we couldn't vote for the Oberth class. Those ships were pure death traps.

June 13 2012, 10:49 PM	#27
Ethros Vice Admiral Location: 1123 6536 5321	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? NX-01 obvs, late Season 3 anyone? Complete with those poor crew members going for a ride

June 13 2012, 11:11 PM	#28
Knight Templar Commodore Location: Oklahoma	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? If I had served on the NX-01 Enterprise I think I would've eaten, worked, and slept in a spacesuit.

June 15 2012, 08:02 PM	#30
SilentP Commodore Location: is in a very lonely Corner of the Circle	Re: What Trek Ship suffered the most damage and beating? I vote for the NX for the above photo's reason. That and the fact that it couldn't replicate replacement parts like the others. Also doesn't help that the ship was essentially the first of a new generation of human starships (not just a new class like Voyager and the Defiant was, but a whole new level of ship capability) so the technology only has a few years of familiarity to it's engineers (skilled though they are).