Who Should Have Left in Season Four? - Page 6

Guy Gardener · November 8 2009, 07:59 AM

Harry had Non Sequitor to prove that he had what it took, even though he was just playing "Clarence" to Tom's Jimmy Stewart from it's a wonderful life, and they shared about evenly the Chute which had some powerful stuff rolling around in the atmosphere, meanwhile warhead, favourite Son and Nightingale all prooved that he was as much a drop kick as he was when he collaborated with the Hirogen in the Killing game or accepted orders from an imaginary command structure which had the Doctor at the top of the totem in Workforce, not that he wasn't half as persuasive as kes in Getting captain Tuvok to engage a Vidiaan fleet to save Janeway from giving into Chakotay's sexual advances.

It's like the writers room despised him.

J. Allen · November 8 2009, 08:24 AM

I voted Neelix, but it was a real effort because I wanted to vote for Harry Kim. In all the episodes I've seen, I just can't find a real use for that guy. Neelix more so, but only by a hair.

J.

Gep Malakai · November 8 2009, 08:32 AM

So why didn't you just vote for Harry then?

Guy Gardener · November 8 2009, 08:44 AM

Well, if the ship crashed and the power gave out and the ship was left to lottery who would eat who first before even that semblance of society collapsed... I just think that you could cut a better steak off Mr Kim's carcass than Neelixs.

Besides, just the ordeal of having to remove that hedgehogs pelt makes whatever he has to offer almost too much effort to bother with until it's a choice between eating him or yourself.

God, could you imagine Janeway trying to be egalitarian about it? Everyone loses a leg to the lottery first, and then an arm and then their other leg before they put these buggers out of their misery.

J. Allen · November 8 2009, 08:46 AM

Gep Malakai wrote:

So why didn't you just vote for Harry then?

Because I said this:

I voted Neelix, but it was a real effort because I wanted to vote for Harry Kim. In all the episodes I've seen, I just can't find a real use for that guy. Neelix more so, but only by a hair.

J.

J.

Guy Gardener · November 8 2009, 08:59 AM

So you're with on the pelt then?

Admiral Shran · November 8 2009, 08:03 PM

Definitely Neelix. Any chance to get rid of him should have been jumped upon. They even had a chance to kill him off through suicide and they passed.

Guy Gardener · November 8 2009, 11:34 PM

if it was just about money? Why did they get rid of the little girl who they probably paid the least? Is it bigotist to assume sexism?

Or do we assume that she and Wand (Funny typo! Another word which means penis.) who had about as much air time and profile on the show were pulling down similar folding which is why they were the two on the chopping block more so then they sucked harder than anyone else.

Pemmer Harge · November 8 2009, 11:35 PM

Thing is, although Neelix was always kind of annoying, he did get more tolerable after he stopped going out with Kes. I actually found his exit quite touching, which is more than I can say for the rest of the crew thanks to Endgame.

Voyagerian · November 9 2009, 05:03 PM

Lynx wrote:

No one should have been kicked out. Voyager had the best cast of all the Trek shows, there was no need for any change.

They should have kept the original characters even if they had to add Seven.

Hi, fellow STV fans! Newbie here, so be kind(And big Voyager fan, duh!) At any rate, I agree with my cohort here...I liked all the characters mentioned-especially Kes, whom I will state for the record straightaway I am a longtime fan of, and Jen. I feel they all have merit, though, I am not a big Seven fan-but that's just my personal taste, of course, and yes, she was apparently 'The Spock or Data' of STV....Had Jen been able to stay on, I would have had no problem with Jeri there....but as usual, fans don't get to make 'the big decisions'....