RSS iconTwitter iconFacebook icon

The Trek BBS title image

The Trek BBS statistics

Threads: 145,575
Posts: 5,733,818
Members: 25,809
Currently online: 410
Newest member: shalhekhaeat


Welcome! The Trek BBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans. Please login to see our full range of forums as well as the ability to send and receive private messages, track your favourite topics and of course join in the discussions.

If you are a new visitor, join us for free. If you are an existing member please login below. Note: for members who joined under our old messageboard system, please login with your display name not your login name.


Go Back   The Trek BBS > Star Trek TV Series > Voyager

Voyager There's coffee in this forum!

Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old April 6 2009, 08:04 PM   #586
Frazzled
Commander
 
Frazzled's Avatar
 
Location: The mess hall
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

I
said yes to the train one and no to the organ one, and I tried to rationalise it to myself by talking about free will and how nobody has the right to kill another.
And to make the train one a parallel to the Tuvix situation you'd have to say 'a train is going to run over one of your oldest and most trusted friends plus another guy you like, or you can pull a lever so it just runs over one person who you also like but have only known for a short while'.

Actually as I was typing that I realised it's more 'a train has already run over one of your oldest and most trusted friends plus another guy you like, but you can make time go backwards by pulling the lever and killing another guy instead....' which just makes my head hurt
Frazzled is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 6 2009, 08:29 PM   #587
DGCatAniSiri
Captain
 
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

GodBen wrote: View Post
Here is a thought experiment I read once which fits into this discussion about Tuvix. You are at the switch controlling the fork for some railroad tracks. The train is on course to run over and kill five people, but you have the choice of throwing the switch and having the train only kill one person. Do you do it? Most people answer yes.

Now imagine there is five people desperately in need of new organs or they will die within a few hours. Would you order the death of one healthy person in order to harvest the organs you need? Most people answer no.

They are very similar situations, but the way the question is posed changes how people answer it.
It's funny, I was discussing the fact that guns make killing impersonal and easier with someone earlier and they brought up the same basic idea of those scenarios - when someone has the distance between them, not being the one pulling the trigger or something, they could do these things, but make them face their victim and they couldn't.

Anyway, I can't really comment on Tuvix - I don't think I've seen it since it first aired or a repeat not long after, because my memories of it are pretty hazy.
DGCatAniSiri is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 6 2009, 09:52 PM   #588
TheGodBen
Rear Admiral
 
TheGodBen's Avatar
 
Location: Ireland
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

Resolutions (**½)

Before we start let me just say that I'm not a J/C shipper. I was an Odo/Kira shipper, a Josh/Donna shipper and a very big Daphne/Niles shipper, but I was never a J/C shipper. This episode is not my holy grail.

The episode moves too fast. There is at least a month's worth of time that goes by in this episode, and that is something which should have been able to fill a whole arc. Why not do a few episodes with Janeway and Chakotay on the planet while Tuvok is in command? As it is the story feels far too rushed and the narrative gaps are too big.

The whole plot is contrived, the idea that they can survive on the planet without any symptoms but not on the ship doesn't make much sense. I'm sure they could replicate the environmental conditions of the planet on the ship somehow; in the last episode they managed to make two people from one, so don't tell me their technology isn't advanced enough. You just have to accept this plot contrivance and move on.

The plot on Voyager should have been so much better. When I realised the set-up I figured this would be an excellent opportunity to show some dissent amongst the crew now that the two main leaders are gone, but instead we just got a standard "Vulcan as captain being too logical for emotional crew" storyline. The Galileo Seven, The Gamesters of Triskelion, That Which Survives... TOS covered this concept 30 years ago. TNG even did a few of these episodes with Data, nothing new or interesting was brought to the table. I liked the fact that Kim finally got to do something, but that wasn't enough to save this story. And Tuvok changed his mind far too easily after Kes talked to him.

What works in this episode is the J/C stuff on the planet. Both of their characters come to life in new and interesting ways once the pressures of command are taken off their shoulders, and I really liked Chakotay in this episode. What I didn't like was the monkey, it was a metaphor for something but I'm damned if I know what and it just came across as silly.

What bothers me is the ambiguity of the ending. Some might say that it was supposed to be that way so that we could use our imagination to fill in the missing scene, but I think it was a cowardly attempt to shy away from any consequences. They could have kissed, they could have cuddled, they could have had the most passionate night the Delta Quadrant has ever seen! Or they could have made some soup in the bathtub to eat over the next few weeks. We'll never know.

This reminds me an awful lot of the BSG episode Unfinished Business, that episode showed Roslin and Adama getting high on New Caprica and snuggling up out in the wilderness, but we are never told if they did anything more. (Unless that was on the extended cut which they didn't put on the R2 DVDs. ) The difference is that that scene is where Roslin first starts talking about building a cabin, and this has an emotional resonance throughout the rest of the series, ending with an absolutely beautiful shot in the finale. I don't remember Resolutions having much weight later in the series.

The scenes on the planet are good, the scenes on Voyager are not, they copped out in the ending and the whole thing was a little rushed.
__________________
...so many different suns...

"No one is actually dead until the ripples they cause in the world die away." - The immortal Terry Pratchett
TheGodBen is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 6 2009, 10:46 PM   #589
Praetor
Vice Admiral
 
Praetor's Avatar
 
Location: The fine line between continuity and fanwank.
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

What a surprise. I agree with GodBen again. (How's that ego going, champ?)

Most members of the VGR forum know that while I can definitely appreciate the chemistry between the two, I'm not a J/C shipper for the practicality argument - I think Janeway and Chakotay should have acted like grownups on the ship and having a relationship would be a violation of the chain of command and the best interests of the crew. To me, it's best played with tension, not consummation, because it kind of steals a sense of authority/credibility from their characters. I've gone into it before in the J/C thread and don't want to do it again here.

However...

For 'Resolutions,' I would have been fine with seeing that Janeway and Chakotay had given up on ever getting home and decided to act on those feelings here, and then had to deal with what they had done for the rest of the show. I don't really feel like we ever saw any indication of them dealing with anything, so that, combined with the purposeful ambiguity of the episode, seems to indicate to me at least that whatever happened, it wasn't so major as for them to not get over it. Still, it's rather enjoyable. Overall, I think VGR was often guilty of implying things happened and not actually dealing with the consequences of what was implied to have happened.

And I agree that the B-plot was rather boring and predictable and that the plot device used to get Janeway and Chakotay on the planet was pretty forced and technobabbly, especially after, as GB points out, we saw two people combined into one and then separate again last episode.

In essence:
GodBen wrote: View Post
The scenes on the planet are good, the scenes on Voyager are not, they copped out in the ending and the whole thing was a little rushed.
Overall, an enjoyable outing riddled with missed opportunities and occasional missteps.
__________________
"If you can't take a little bloody nose, maybe you ought to go back home and crawl under your bed. It's not safe out here. It's wondrous, with treasures to satiate desires both subtle and gross; but it's not for the timid." - Q
Praetor is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 6 2009, 11:47 PM   #590
Mareika
Captain
 
Mareika's Avatar
 
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

GodBen, every day I read your reviews and I like them.
Although I`m a great Voyagerfan I have to admit, that you are right with many of your statements. And I think I still will be a great Voyagerfan after reading all of your reviews, because I like the crew.
I have to admit that I was a little nervous when I saw that you now have written a review to Resolutions because I VERY like this episode (except of the ending) and it`s one of my alltime fav episodes.
I can say you are right with that episode once more. I have to agree.
I`m very glad you liked the scenes on the planet and you liked Chakotay on the planet. So do I.

Last edited by Mareika; April 6 2009 at 11:48 PM. Reason: error
Mareika is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 12:19 AM   #591
StarryEyed
Commodore
 
StarryEyed's Avatar
 
Location: Florida Keys
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

I'm not a shipper at all; I would be reading Harlequin romance novels if I was into that stuff. I agree with GodBen though that they missed a golden opportunity here. Janeway and Chuckles should have done the nasty in this episode. It would have really complicated the Captain/First Officer professional relationship and generated interesting story possibilities.

The way the crew reacted to Tuvok was essentially mutinous. Tuvok was lawfully in command and was acting in accordance with Captain Janeway's wishes. This should have been majorly followed up on.
StarryEyed is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 01:19 AM   #592
TheGodBen
Rear Admiral
 
TheGodBen's Avatar
 
Location: Ireland
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

Praetor wrote: View Post
What a surprise. I agree with GodBen again. (How's that ego going, champ?)
Pretty good, my ego has now reached level 4 godhood. With another few days of you agreeing with me I should reach level 5.

Mareika wrote: View Post
I`m very glad you liked the scenes on the planet and you liked Chakotay on the planet. So do I.
I really liked those scenes, it showed a completely different side of Chakotay but it still felt like him. I think they pulled that off quite well.

StarryEyed wrote: View Post
The way the crew reacted to Tuvok was essentially mutinous. Tuvok was lawfully in command and was acting in accordance with Captain Janeway's wishes. This should have been majorly followed up on.
I wish it was more mutinous. At first the episode reminded me of the mutiny arc in the final season of BSG, especially when Kim started gathering support amongst the crew. I'm not saying that he should have mounted a proper mutiny and seized control of the ship, but a bit more than what we saw would have been nice.


By the way, three torpedoes were fired in this episode (one off-screen) and I forgot to update the counter.

Torpedoes: 14/38
__________________
...so many different suns...

"No one is actually dead until the ripples they cause in the world die away." - The immortal Terry Pratchett
TheGodBen is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 01:48 AM   #593
kimc
Coffee Mod
 
Location: Minneapolis, MN USA
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

GodBen wrote: View Post
What bothers me is the ambiguity of the ending. Some might say that it was supposed to be that way so that we could use our imagination to fill in the missing scene, but I think it was a cowardly attempt to shy away from any consequences. They could have kissed, they could have cuddled, they could have had the most passionate night the Delta Quadrant has ever seen! Or they could have made some soup in the bathtub to eat over the next few weeks. We'll never know.
For what it's worth the original script floating around the net has a kiss in that scene.

GodBen wrote: View Post
This reminds me an awful lot of the BSG episode Unfinished Business, that episode showed Roslin and Adama getting high on New Caprica and snuggling up out in the wilderness, but we are never told if they did anything more. (Unless that was on the extended cut which they didn't put on the R2 DVDs. ) The difference is that that scene is where Roslin first starts talking about building a cabin, and this has an emotional resonance throughout the rest of the series, ending with an absolutely beautiful shot in the finale. I don't remember Resolutions having much weight later in the series.
Yeah, well Roslin and Adama were allowed to be grownups. This brings me to one of my beefs with Trek in general is that whatever sex there is is dumbed down sex - titillation instead of passion, fetishism instead of realistic relationships. Paris/B'Elanna is one of the rare exceptions to this imo.

As for the reviews I like them fine but I'm not too crazy about the rating system. I think your ratings are often lower than the review warrants. I know you've been taking off for episodes that could have been done on TNG but that argument reminds me of my visit to a modern art museum in Paris. I was standing there looking at a canvas that was completely white except for one stripe down the side. When I said something like "Why the heck is this considered art - I could have done that!" the response was "But you didn't do that."

Sure some episodes could have been done on TNG but the fact is they weren't - the TNG writers didn't think of them but the Voyager writers did. They should be judged on their own merits, imo.
__________________
I'm certainly less inclined to bash Voyager now, it is not nearly as bad a show as many people make it out to be. - TheGodBen

Avatar by B'Elanna.
kimc is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 03:41 AM   #594
Praetor
Vice Admiral
 
Praetor's Avatar
 
Location: The fine line between continuity and fanwank.
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

I think you made some good points about Trek's treatment of relationships, kimc, but I still think GodBen's rating system is fair. The creators of VGR went out of their way to create a scenario where they would be able to escape the 'traps' of the TNG format, and not living up to that potential is, IMO, worthy of a half-star deduction at the least.
__________________
"If you can't take a little bloody nose, maybe you ought to go back home and crawl under your bed. It's not safe out here. It's wondrous, with treasures to satiate desires both subtle and gross; but it's not for the timid." - Q
Praetor is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 04:03 AM   #595
kimc
Coffee Mod
 
Location: Minneapolis, MN USA
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

^ I'm off to paint stripes on blank canvases.
__________________
I'm certainly less inclined to bash Voyager now, it is not nearly as bad a show as many people make it out to be. - TheGodBen

Avatar by B'Elanna.
kimc is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 04:32 AM   #596
Gotham Central
Vice Admiral
 
Location: Chicago, IL
View Gotham Central's Twitter Profile
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

kimc wrote: View Post
GodBen wrote: View Post
What bothers me is the ambiguity of the ending. Some might say that it was supposed to be that way so that we could use our imagination to fill in the missing scene, but I think it was a cowardly attempt to shy away from any consequences. They could have kissed, they could have cuddled, they could have had the most passionate night the Delta Quadrant has ever seen! Or they could have made some soup in the bathtub to eat over the next few weeks. We'll never know.
For what it's worth the original script floating around the net has a kiss in that scene.

GodBen wrote: View Post
This reminds me an awful lot of the BSG episode Unfinished Business, that episode showed Roslin and Adama getting high on New Caprica and snuggling up out in the wilderness, but we are never told if they did anything more. (Unless that was on the extended cut which they didn't put on the R2 DVDs. ) The difference is that that scene is where Roslin first starts talking about building a cabin, and this has an emotional resonance throughout the rest of the series, ending with an absolutely beautiful shot in the finale. I don't remember Resolutions having much weight later in the series.
Yeah, well Roslin and Adama were allowed to be grownups. This brings me to one of my beefs with Trek in general is that whatever sex there is is dumbed down sex - titillation instead of passion, fetishism instead of realistic relationships. Paris/B'Elanna is one of the rare exceptions to this imo.

As for the reviews I like them fine but I'm not too crazy about the rating system. I think your ratings are often lower than the review warrants. I know you've been taking off for episodes that could have been done on TNG but that argument reminds me of my visit to a modern art museum in Paris. I was standing there looking at a canvas that was completely white except for one stripe down the side. When I said something like "Why the heck is this considered art - I could have done that!" the response was "But you didn't do that."

Sure some episodes could have been done on TNG but the fact is they weren't - the TNG writers didn't think of them but the Voyager writers did. They should be judged on their own merits, imo.
Um...in terms of relationships for adults...I think that Kira and Bariel, Kira/Odo, Miles/Keiko, Sisko/Kassidy were all handled well with everyone acting like reasonable adults.
__________________
Well maybe I'm the faggot America.
I'm not a part of a redneck agenda.
Now everybody do the propaganda.
And sing along in the age of paranoia

Green Day
Gotham Central is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 04:35 AM   #597
Gotham Central
Vice Admiral
 
Location: Chicago, IL
View Gotham Central's Twitter Profile
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

Praetor wrote: View Post
I think you made some good points about Trek's treatment of relationships, kimc, but I still think GodBen's rating system is fair. The creators of VGR went out of their way to create a scenario where they would be able to escape the 'traps' of the TNG format, and not living up to that potential is, IMO, worthy of a half-star deduction at the least.

I think that GodBen's ratings system is perfectly fair. I think that some people have a hardtime with the fact that its fairness simply exposes the major weaknesses of Voyager's execution.
__________________
Well maybe I'm the faggot America.
I'm not a part of a redneck agenda.
Now everybody do the propaganda.
And sing along in the age of paranoia

Green Day
Gotham Central is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 03:53 PM   #598
TheGodBen
Rear Admiral
 
TheGodBen's Avatar
 
Location: Ireland
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

kimc wrote: View Post
This brings me to one of my beefs with Trek in general is that whatever sex there is is dumbed down sex - titillation instead of passion, fetishism instead of realistic relationships. Paris/B'Elanna is one of the rare exceptions to this imo.
I agree, I wish that relationships and sex in Trek was dealt with more realistically and with more maturity, but I guess people just see it as a family show now and it has trouble if it tries to escape from that box it found itself in. I know that when I was a kid I used to hate all the romance episodes on the principle that romance is boring and it wasn't until later that I began to appreciate those shows. I guess Star Trek just doesn't want to lose the young audience.

As for the reviews I like them fine but I'm not too crazy about the rating system. I think your ratings are often lower than the review warrants.
I watch each episode fully aware that I'm going to be commenting about it in this thread, and usually I get a feeling as to what score an episode will have while watching it. I consider this my emotional response to the episode. After that I spend some time thinking about the episode trying to determine my intellectual response and sometimes that changes the score either up or down. While my reviews are usually short, sometimes it can take 20 to 30 minutes for me to write them because of this.

For example, Resolutions was scored at around 3.5 for most of the episode, but then I didn't like the ending and it dropped to 3. As I thought about it afterwards I really began to feel that it was a cop-out ending and that the story would have worked better over multiple episodes, so I felt I could only give it 2.5.

When I watched Prime Factors back in season 1 I was scoring it at 3.5 for most of the episode, but the final 15 minutes pushed it up to 4.5. When I thought about it afterwards I realised that the episode was exploring the exact issues I wanted to be explored and it did so very well, so I gave it 5.

I know you've been taking off for episodes that could have been done on TNG but that argument reminds me of my visit to a modern art museum in Paris. I was standing there looking at a canvas that was completely white except for one stripe down the side. When I said something like "Why the heck is this considered art - I could have done that!" the response was "But you didn't do that."
I remember when I went to the Louvre in Paris, one of the first things I on the route was the Mona Lisa. There was a huge crowd surrounding it and taking photos and in order to see it I would have had to shove my way through the crowd as though I were in some form of rugby scrum. I decided to stand up on a bench instead and saw it over everyone's heads, but nobody could see it properly anyway because it was stored behind bulletproof glass.

I turned around to get off the bench and there was this magnificent painting in front of me. It was two stories high and took up almost the entire wall. It was of a battle scene, and in the sky had storm-clouds and angels, it was epic and it was ambitious and... only two other people were looking at it because everyone was huddled over the Mona Lisa.

That's the day when my faith in humanity began to fall, when I realised that people weren't interested in the ambitious yet flawed work of art, they were only there to see the famous painting and to snap a picture of it.

That story has no relevance to the conversation other than to explain why I'm so grumpy.

Sure some episodes could have been done on TNG but the fact is they weren't - the TNG writers didn't think of them but the Voyager writers did. They should be judged on their own merits, imo.
I do judge the episode by its merits, and then I take half a star off if it is in the style of TNG. While I am reviewing the show one episode at a time I am not trying to perform a review of each episode, I am trying to review the series as a whole. In the first few episodes this show told me it was going to be different than TNG and it was going to explore new issues which TNG couldn't. When an episode fails to live up to the promise of the early episodes then it is letting the team down.

Gotham Central wrote: View Post
I think that GodBen's ratings system is perfectly fair. I think that some people have a hard time with the fact that its fairness simply exposes the major weaknesses of Voyager's execution.
And it is only going to get even fairer in the future. I have decided that once Voyager uses up 38 torpedoes I am going to deduct half a star from any episodes where we see more being used without an explanation as to where they came from. I have also decided that after Voyager loses five shuttles I will deduct half a star for any future shuttles we see because I have a hard time believing Voyager had more than five to begin with. So if an episode contains an unexplained shuttle, unexplained torpedoes and it could have been done on TNG, the episode will lose 1 and a half stars.

I thought about this for some time and I can understand why some people might think I am being incredibly unfair about this, and maybe I am. But these were things pointed out as being finite in earlier episodes of the series and all it takes is a throwaway line to the shuttle and torpedo building team led by Lt Carey for this situation to be resolved.

Like I said, I'm grumpy.
__________________
...so many different suns...

"No one is actually dead until the ripples they cause in the world die away." - The immortal Terry Pratchett
TheGodBen is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 05:40 PM   #599
Praetor
Vice Admiral
 
Praetor's Avatar
 
Location: The fine line between continuity and fanwank.
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

Grumpy, but fair.

(I'd be curious to see you do this for DS9, btw.)
__________________
"If you can't take a little bloody nose, maybe you ought to go back home and crawl under your bed. It's not safe out here. It's wondrous, with treasures to satiate desires both subtle and gross; but it's not for the timid." - Q
Praetor is offline   Reply With Quote
Old April 7 2009, 06:31 PM   #600
TheGodBen
Rear Admiral
 
TheGodBen's Avatar
 
Location: Ireland
Re: A Hater Revisits Voyager

I could do it for DS9, but I have to do Voyager and Enterprise first so it would be around a year before I got started.

I'll never get around to watching The Wire at this rate.
__________________
...so many different suns...

"No one is actually dead until the ripples they cause in the world die away." - The immortal Terry Pratchett
TheGodBen is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:43 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.