First Clear Picture of the Narada *Spoilers?* [not final toy image]

[Klingon Empire]

I just want this movie to reflect on TOS. As it is now, it looks nothing like TOS.

[Admiral Buzzkill]

It's good that the Giant Squid was able to get work in "Star Trek" since it was fired from "Watchmen."

[Klingon Empire]

Exactly. And Rob, are you suggesting that I, and everyone else on this forum, are goobers?

[Samuel T. Cogley]

I certainly am.

[Klingon Empire]

And so am I. But I just wanted conformation.

[daveyNY]

Starship Polaris wrote:

---

The future of what?

Nothing in this film is visually designed to fit snugly into the old continuity. It's meaningless to look at a prop, or a set or a model and ask "how does this fit between X and Y that we've seen" or say "this is out of place next to thus-and-such a thing that came before" because everything has been redesigned for this film. The very premise that everything can be charted in its place in previous Trek design is a mistaken one. They are using what makes sense to them to use and changing what they choose to change.

It is that simple.

Which is just about Everything...

And which will probably (IMHO), make Trek no more appealing to 'The Masses', than it was before hand.

Just because You Can Change Everything, Doesn't Mean You Should.

And, to Quote You... IT IS, That Simple...

Samuel T. Cogley wrote:

---

I certainly am.

You would!
>ducks and snickers<

[Klingon Empire]

Throws crappy Playmates phaser. (J/K)

I actually agee with you.

>Ducks and snickers<

[Admiral Buzzkill]

daveyNY wrote:

---

Just because You Can Change Everything, Doesn't Mean You Should.

It can't do "Star Trek" one iota of harm.

If this movie tanks, all the fans who are horrified by the changes will have exactly what they have now in terms of "Star Trek" and they can congratulate one another on being right.

What they can't have is what they want from the studio. Not now, not next year, not ever...because the only people to whom that makes sense are a few million trekkies and their numbers are dwindling rather than growing.

[middyseafort]

Starship Polaris wrote:

---

...because the only people to whom that makes sense are a few million trekkies and their numbers are dwindling rather than growing.

This reminds me of something a certain Vorlon from another science-fiction series said once:

They are a dying breed. We should let them pass.

[Cyke101]

Klingon Empire wrote:

---

I just want this movie to reflect on TOS. As it is now, it looks nothing like TOS.

"Take out the giant squid! Put back the giant green hand!"

From what I understand, the Narada is from the TNG/DS9/VOY era. So sticking by the story, no matter what vessel goes back in time, it probably wouldn't have looked like TOS anyway.

[middyseafort]

Cyke101 wrote:

---

"Take out the giant squid! Put back the giant green hand!"

Screw that. I want Floating Abraham Lincoln in Space. (Oh... that sounds like a good sitcom!)

[daveyNY]

Starship Polaris wrote:

---

It can't do "Star Trek" one iota of harm.

If this movie tanks, all the fans who are horrified by the changes will have exactly what they have now in terms of "Star Trek" and they can congratulate one another on being right.

What they can't have is what they want from the studio. Not now, not next year, not ever...because the only people to whom that makes sense are a few million trekkies and their numbers are dwindling rather than growing.

Pehaps... but driving away the (according to you) few of Us left, may not be such a great thing either.

I'm not horrified by the changes....

I'm disappointed by the fact that They felt that They had to change so much.

And I don't want Trek to fail, but unlike you I don't believe that keeping more of the original intact, would have been such a horrible thing either.

I also doubt that there will be very many of US going around congratulating Ourselves that Trek has failed, once again.

You make such matter-of-fact statments... and really don't have anything but your opinion to back them up... for all I know you may be right, but having you constantly shoving them down folks throats who post dissenting opinions is getting rather tiresome.

Perhaps those dwindling few that felt keeping more of the original intact are correct, perhaps not...but We will never know now.

As far as the topic-at-hand....

Since the Narada is apparently from the TNG Era, I have no problem with how it looks and I like what another posted here earlier... it does kinda sorta have the same feel as the Romulan ships from ENTERPRISE.
A nice nod there.

[Klingon Empire]

It's a giant space squid. It freeks me out and does not give me a single trek feeling in my hole body.

[number6]

Klingon Empire wrote:

---

It's a giant space squid. It freeks me out and does not give me a single trek feeling in my hole body.

That's what I like about. It's something we haven't seen.

[Klingon Empire]

That is true. But Romulan ships from TNG/DS9/VOY era looked like birds, not squids.