Yeah I don't get it either. I assume it's some kind of Trek lit character fight thread or something. The character is actually Idun Asmund from "Reunion".
Going by the thread title, I'm gonna say it's tbbs member vs member. In that spirit I suggest Christopher vs Anwar
Its simple, you pick the winner and write a new challaenge. Worf Frankie Eyes(Chalmers vs Liam Bilby in a turf war. The duck posted: From the starting post: Only trek stuff should appear
Ro, while content to appear in TNG, isn't interested in appearing in spin-off material until the novels, which don't require the actor. Thus, Ro doesn't show for the fight and Asmund wins by default. However, she's mistaken for her twin and a squad of Daa'Vit assassins in the crowd take her down. Ro is then declared winner in absentia. RO WINS! Anwar forms an unprecedented, unthinkable alliance between Niners and Voyagers, sending shockwaves through the BBS. Christopher forms a similar alliance of TOS and TNG. The two coalitions circle uneasily. Anwar might attack, but fears Christopher's carefully-researched refutals. For his part, Christopher is peaceful, but the scientific inaccuracy of Voyager cannot go unchallenged. In the end, Anwar offers "Threshold" as a sacrifice peace offering. Christopher accepts, on the condition that he also get a novel-length version of "Places of Exile". It is agreed, and hostilities are averted. EVERYONE WINS! Worf attacks Astall with a bat'leth. Astall squeals in joy and tries to hug him. Worf uses mok'bara moves to flip her onto the floor, where she squees and tries to share his pain in a supportive manner. Worf loses his temper, storms out and jumps to ''Full Circle''. BEYER'S BANK BALANCE WINS!!
Christopher vs. Timo. The universe explodes (in a scientifically correct manner, which is explained in detail)
"vs" comparisons seem popular, though they're not worth anything as serious contests, of course. There's never any actual logic behind this sort of thing. It's not a measured or illuminating comparison, it's pure fluff. People just throw out two characters, pieces of equipment, whatever, and then the respondant arbitrarily chooses a "winner". You can justify the choice however you choose, and pick the winner on a whim. I assume Yevetha is just giving us a "game thread" for the lit forum. Some people, though, will need actual structure and genuine basis for comparison before it's in any way fun for them. Sometimes these things take off, sometimes they don't. Yevetha, one day I'll tell you about First Noname'given and the Ketracel Purple...
I'm sorry, no. We're not doing this. It's essentially spam It doesn't make sense Given the use of actual posters could easily lead to trolling Thread closed If there's an issue with this closing please contact me via PM directly. Thanks.