I'm new to the board, so here's my opinion:
I really enjoyed the film. Thought it was awesome and was surprised to find that some hardcore fans like me disliked it intensely.
Kirk is my hero, but even I was not bothered by Spock's "KHAAAN!"
Cumberbatch was a great villain. Loved the cast all around.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, Nimoy's cameo was not integral to the story, but any excuse to have Nimoy as Spock in a Star Trek movie is a good one IMO.
My only complaint, (that I can remember because I haven't seen it in a few months), was that there wasn't enough Karl Urban.
The film made me excited to see more of the Klingons.