View Single Post
Old March 30 2014, 08:45 PM   #656
Fleet Captain
Enterprise1701's Avatar
Location: Sol III, Sector 001, 2015 C.E.
Re: Marvel planning Guardians of the Galaxy movie!

Reverend wrote: View Post
From the trailer I suspect that however he got into deep space it happened when he was a child. Assuming the actor is about the same age of the character, the fact that cassette walkmans went obsolete sometime in the early 90's and that the Blue Swede cover of 'Hooked on a Feeling' is from the mid-70's, I'd say he was about 10 year old in the late 80's when it happened.

Which seems to line up with the latest version of his origin as when his mother was killed. Indeed, maybe the song has some personal significance. A memory of his mother perhaps and the last tangible link to home.

I'm just speculating now, but I think it'd be better if they alter the origin a bit to have him abducted by those aliens as a child (intentionally or otherwise.) The idea that he "joined NASA" is a good explanation as to how he got halfway across the universe seems like a little bit of a stretch.

Personally I think the concept of an orphan fending for himself in a (quite literally) alien environment is a lot more interesting than an astronaut who lucked upon interstellar travel just because he wanted to really badly. Oliver Twist in space if you will. Obviously someone out there would have had to have taken him in for a time, maybe even raised him to an extent.

Alidar Jarok wrote: View Post
I think it's clear that Lady Sif does not have full knowledge of everyone who has reached Earth.
I don't disagree, but you'd think Heimdall would have noticed at least. I mean that's his job, no? Those Kree must have been *very* sneaky.

I don't think Chitauri space is another dimension. Whether the Nine Realms are or are not is the big debate (I don't personally think it changes much either way). The main view, however, is all of known space is in Midgard, while the other eight realms are in other dimensions. That means the Chitauri are in Midgard. The portal that opened that gave them a shortcut, iirc from the Avengers, was created with the Space Stone by Loki. I don't think it was a portal to another universe, unless there's something from the comics suggesting that the Chitauri are not from normal space.
Based on how things are presented in the movies, it seems as though all of the Nine Realms are all in the same universe, just spread across the cosmos. As if the Virgo Supercluster is just one "branch" of Yggdrasil. Indeed, isn't an "alternate dimension" just an often used, but technically incorrect way of saying "alternate universe"? Clearly everything is supposed to be in the same universe, even if Asgard itself is somehow isolated (and yet surrounded by stars, moons and planets?)
I know from reading some comics as well as watching various cartoon adaptations that in Earth-616, Asgard and the other realms are indeed supposed to be other dimensions. However, I'm confused as to the intent in the MCU because in Thor, Thor used Hubble snapshots to explain the Nine Realms to Jane Foster.

And the difference between "dimension" and "universe" differs depending on which franchise/work you're talking about. But then there's Star Trek. Would you call a subspace fold or whatever from Star Trek an alternate dimension or an alternate universe? Cause then there's parallel quantum realities like the mirror universe and the Abramsverse.
Enterprise1701 is offline   Reply With Quote