STC's FaceBook page is overflowing with gushing praise. I can't blame fans hungry for genuine feeling Star Trek.
I, myself, loved this on so many levels. That said there a number of critiques and observations I could make, but they all would be out of love for TOS and the respect for what these folks are trying to do.
I can't in all good conscience rate it a 10, but I can give it an 8.
A big plus for this is the kind of stories they're trying to do. In the greater scheme of things the events in these stories are small scale, but that doesn't make them unimportant or any less poignant. They get that many of TOS' best moments were character drama as opposed to big space battles. I reiterate that I could easily see the original cast doing these stories.