Tom Hendricks wrote:
Don't pitchers only get considered on their pitching? So why can't a DH be judged solely on his hitting?
I think the attitude is that if you vote a DH in, you are leaving some other worthy "full-time" player.
Someone has to make the case for the DH to be considered seperate just like the pitchers are.
If Edgar doesn't make it, Big Papi has no chance.