View Single Post
Old January 4 2014, 09:40 PM   #36
sonak
Vice Admiral
 
Location: in a figment of a mediocre mind's imagination
Re: "In the Pale Moonlight'

Gaith wrote: View Post
^ Anytime.

Bad Thoughts wrote: View Post
I feel that this is another moment in which Ms. Green misses the mark: the more that Garak's independent actions became both surprising and nefarious, the more leeway Sisko would have to see them not as something for which he was responsible. He would have passed it off as being double-crossed by Garak. No, Garak's actions were of the right dimension so that Sisko should have legitimately felt responsible.
But Sisko would still have been responsible for enabling Garak's misdeeds in such a scenario.

Anyway, Green's main point, IMO, is the choice is an easy one. For good or for ill, a wartime ship/station CO shouldn't hesitate to potentially sacrifice three or four foreign civilians to save millions of his own. In light of Sisko's histrionic agonizing, "ItPM" isn't nearly as mature as many make it out to be. One could very well argue that it's in fact far more naive about humanity than just about any non-DS9 ep.

historically, you could argue that during major wars just about every democracy has done far worse things than what Sisko did in ITPM.

Just to give U.S. examples: suspension of habeas corpus, jailing those who spoke out against a war or sought to avoid conscription, conscription itself, jailing American citizens of Japanese dissent, etc. etc.
__________________
"why oh why didn't I take the blue pill?"
sonak is offline   Reply With Quote