This is a fairly tame forum where criticism is concerned. With the exception of a few who can't stop themselves from badmouthing certain individuals on other productions, it's actually a very genteel place.
Or the couple trolls who live on this forum and use it as a medium to constantly prove how smart they they think they are to everyone else.
Ultimately Tommy, the best thing to do is focus on your own product, and get tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, or like Phase II, millions of viewers. What a couple people on a Trek forum say will not affect your success. And it is way better to spend time with people who actually create fan films, not talk about them.
And I would suggest you have an active Facebook group for your fans, and possibly, when you get big enough, your own forum.