I've only seen 2009, and not until last year. The only part I found intriguing was trying to figure out how they did the moving camera beam down on Spock arriving on a crumbling Vulcan. Still not sure how they did it, unless there was a cgi stand-in for some of it. And Quinto's interpretation is an interesting take, though he seemed a bit overly emotional for adult Spock.The most fun was putting it back in the case.
Ouch, that seems a bit harsh.
It still your opinion and I respect that.