View Single Post
Old October 8 2013, 06:05 PM   #10
Nob Akimoto
Captain
 
Location: The People's Republic of Austin
View Nob Akimoto's Twitter Profile
Re: Sorry Johnny, your ship's too small...

Crazy Eddie wrote: View Post
Also... I don't suppose you could be a pal and include the Kelvin and Alt Enterprise in your volumetric analysis. The creeping nerd rage over the Reboot is strong enough that I think I may be the only person in the universe who actually bothers with it anymore.
ST09 Ship Volumes(very rough) All measurements in m:
295m (Saucer scaled to TMP Enterprise):
Enterprise
  • Total: 251,249.14
  • Saucer: 117,122.30
  • Secondary Hull: 33,787.68
  • Nacelle (Single): 50,169.58
Kelvin
  • Total: 176,489.43
  • Saucer: 100,339.17
  • Secondary Hull: 22,845.08
  • Nacelle: 53,305.18

366m (Ryan Church Design Length):
Enterprise
  • Total: 479,823.82
  • Saucer: 223,674.67
  • Secondary Hull: 64,526.12
  • Nacelle (Single): 95,811.51
Kelvin
  • Total: 337,051.22
  • Saucer: 191,623.03
  • Secondary Hull: 43,628.46
  • Nacelle: 101,799.73

725m (Certain Interior/Exterior VFX Shot Length):
Enterprise
  • Total: 3,729,516.76
  • Saucer: 1,738,551.51
  • Secondary Hull: 501,540.86
  • Nacelle (Single): 744,712.19
Kelvin
  • Total: 2,619,791.10
  • Saucer: 1,489,424.38
  • Secondary Hull: 339,110.02
  • Nacelle: 791,256.70

1025m (Supposed Length for Shuttlebay Size):
Enterprise
  • Total: 10,539,260.51
  • Saucer: 4,912,981.62
  • Secondary Hull: 1,417,306.90
  • Nacelle (Single): 2,104,486.00
Kelvin
  • Total: 7,403,281.10
  • Saucer: 4,208,972.00
  • Secondary Hull: 958,292.73
  • Nacelle: 2,236,016.37

For comparison's sake
Galaxy - 5,900,000 m
Enterprise (TOS) - 210,000 m
Enterprise (TMP) - 280,000 m

Basically the two larger end sizes are somewhat preposterous and even the Church 366m might be a bit problematic. Especially when we consider Kelvin is probably meant to have existed in the Prime Timeline as well.
Nob Akimoto is offline   Reply With Quote