You know I used to think ID4 was stupid...and then I saw Signs. Now *that's* stupid.
Actually, I found Signs to be quite good... Very tense and lots of scary moments... The ending resolution and the fact that the Aliens and water don't mix was, yeah, a bit much, but overall the movie was well done, well paced and well written..
I agree. Thought it was very well done, too, in many respects.
My only gripe with it that, in Pennsylvania, there are more guns per household than in any other state in the country, and yet not a single firearm appeared in the movie to be used against the alien invasion on-screen. Probably would have made things a little too easy at that point.