I find it odd that anyone would want a new Star Trek series to simply redo exactly what's already been done. If that's what you want, how do you want anything 'new'? Isn't it better to watch the dvds of the shows you already know you like and leave it at that, instead of hoping for something else that is as likely as not to end up disappointing you (for whatever reason)?
If you've read any of my posts, you'll know that I'm someone who really doesn't want Star Trek back on TV, in any form. But if it does come back, I want it to be recognizably 'Star Trek', not something wearing Star Trek's clothes.