View Single Post
Old October 18 2006, 08:56 PM   #230
Philo
Commodore
 
Philo's Avatar
 
Location: Montréal
Re: USS Grandeur - One... More... Time!

I agree with Cary that, theoretically, that's the way torpedoes are supposed to operate on the show, but I can see where Vulcan is coming from given that, as Kirkunit demonstrates, it's rarely been shown on Trek that torpedoes do much more than go straight and then go boom.

I think that originally this owes mostly to trek being inspired by old-style naval warfare. Torpedoes in trek are much more analagous to 17th century cannon carrying sailing vessels than 20th century submarines and their intelligently guided projectiles.
Philo is offline   Reply With Quote