Define it however you like. I had a blast watching both of them.
Good for you. I liked the first one better than the second. I'm thankful for JJ's Trek for the simple reason that it's helping keep Trek alive...but...
I'm hoping for Trek to return to TV.
I've got close to seven-hundred hours of TV Star Trek sitting on my DVD/Blu-ray shelf. I'm pretty happy with getting a new movie every three-to-four years.