I voted that I want it back as it is what I personally want.
I enjoyed the '09 move, haven't seen the new one yet, but it wasn't Star Trek for me.
Would I want the NuTrek to end? No. I tried to get my children into Trek but they never really got into it. When the '09 movie came out my oldest son, now 32, loved it. So I have a new Trek fan in my family now. Which I consider a great thing. Anything that brings in new people to Trek is a good thing in my opinion.
If there had been an option for both I would have chosen that.