Looks like other trek fans have spoken after that ridiculous list that was set loose on the internet two weeks ago.
Star Trek fans at a Seattle convention ranked the best star trek films and this are their results:
2. First Contact
3. Star Trek 2009
Sadly Access Hollywood did not give us the full list, however Simon Pegg is breathing a sigh of relief. According to him, he can live with STiD placed in 6th position.