this people are the same people that JJ, Orci and the rest of the writers and producers went out of their way to please. that was why they did all the classic trek shout outs and excess homages in STiD.
Now the same people that they were so desperately trying to please have bashed the film endlessly.
Cue for the producers of Trek 3.
Please do your own thing next time and don't try and please a select group of people.
They could have taken a page from Meyer and done it in the vein that 'I owe allegiance only to the stuff in TREK that works for me, and it is my job to make people want and like my vision' ...
thing is, you have to HAVE a vision in order to pull that off -- and some talent. Otherwise, many will harp on the homages as well as the inconsistencies.