The only problem I have with this ranking is that it feels very reactionary. STID would not be ranked this low if it was already a few years old by this point.
STID isn't even ranking that low now. That is a very suspecting poll considering how well polls here at TrekBBS, TrekMovie, etc., place it.
Doesn't help that sites like The Guardian are posting this as some sort of gospel (which is completely ironic considering the response threads on those articles ALSO paint a very different picture.)
Although good thing when someone in the general public see's the word "Trekkie" they stop paying attention immediately anyway, and that's speaking as one!