View Single Post
Old July 17 2013, 10:07 PM   #23
Grant
Fleet Captain
 
Grant's Avatar
 
Re: The Menagerie/The Cage

Push The Button wrote: View Post
Shawnster wrote: View Post
Anwar wrote: View Post
The biggest plot hole in this episode wasn't Mendez, it was how everyone forgot about Morse code and didn't think of getting Pike to communicate that way.
From Menagerie:
MCCOY: We've learned to tie into every human organ in the body except one. The brain.
Except that McCoy's able to quickly rig a remote control for Spock just 2 years later in Spock's Brain.

Morse Code. Or the computer system Hawking uses. Granted, Hawking's tech wasn't available in the 60s, but Morse Code was. Johnny Got His Gun, anyone?

Yeah, that gets my vote for biggest plot hole or oversight.
My wife is a nurse and works with the disabled. She uses a cardboard chart with the letters of the alphabet arranged in a grid to communicate with her patients that can't speak or move. It is as low tech as it gets, but it works, and would have allowed Pike to communicate to Kirk, McCoy and anyone else much more than just the "yes or no" that his beeping chair light allowed in the episode.

Of course, Pike's inability to communicate was essential to the plot, so his being able to warn someone about Spock's plan would have ended the story pretty quickly.


A simple game of 20 questions would have worked using the lights---it was in idiotic bit of dialogue from day 1 and amazing that it got by. They could have simply said, "does this have to do with Spock?

Bingo first guess is right, Spock's plan uncovered.

second idiotic statement Spock nerve piches Chief Humboldt sends false Kirk message and then says to Enterprise, "We'll be warping out in AN HOUR" !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Realy? an hour---extra hard nerve pinch? or did he then hypo him hide the body and then expect no-one wouk come back within an hour and say, "Where's Humboldt?"

I guess no one questioned GR's scripts "hey GR--this makes no sense."

"Hmm, you're fired."

"Any other input? Okay we're all set."
Grant is offline   Reply With Quote