As big of a fan as I was, I have to agree that it's more of a closed storyline type show than something like Star Trek which can be re-invented.
I still think I would like to see a series of movies to go with Blood & Chrome, following Adama's exploits in that ghost fleet, there's definitely some stories to tell there. But I could also be okay with closing this chapter and giving it a few more years to let somebody else tackle the subject.
And I wouldn't mind a theatrical trilogy from Singer that would be a nice complete re-telling either.
And as far as this forum goes, yeah, let it go. We're going to need the slot for a Star Wars forum soon enough anyways.