I am not particularly a big fan of Mulgrew, Beltran or Ryan. I draw a line between the actor and the character. I love Voyager's characters, not so much the actors.
It's funny because most of us only know the characters the actors play. I personally know none of the actors and would certainly not prejudice any opinion I might have of them as individuals, in the unlikely event we ever meet, from gossip. Obviously you have met some or all of them and can make this comparison.