Reeve was also awesome as Evil Superman In Superman III.
I did like the junkyard battle with Clark and Evil Superman. Reeve looked demented when Evil Supes was screaming at Clark to come at him. And I loved it when Evil Superman blew out the Olympic Torch when it was about to get lit. What a douche.
Annette O'Toole is pretty much charming in whatever she's in. Love her.
It's not that I hated Cavill in the role. Far from it. I'd go so far as to say he's my second favorite Superman, but the second half of MOS really, really could have benefitted from toning down the action.