View Single Post
Old July 7 2013, 10:33 PM   #143
Vice Admiral
T'Girl's Avatar
Location: Looking for somewhere to put my urine sample down
Re: Star Trek morality test - best and worst episodes

T'Girl wrote: View Post
sonak wrote: View Post
Just because a humanitarian intervention is doable in one scenario (because of population size, resources, etc.) doesn't mean that the Federation would somehow be forced to intervene throughout the galaxy.
Well of course not, it would be a question of priorities and assets.
Anwar wrote: View Post
Yes, but I'm talking about setting a precedent for Homeward-level types of crises. The ones that would require thousands of starships working around the clock.
This has already been addressed.

Yes, have the Prime Directive policy include that when a species is facing utter extinction that Starfleet can move all or part of the species off the doomed world. Direct contact with a primative (or not so primative) species.

Because survival trumps contamination.

No, this doesn't mean the Starfleet then has to endlessly prowl the galaxy looking for species to move. The only precedent that would be create is that the Prime Directive recognizes that not all situation are the same. If Starfleet has the assets availible, in place, at that time, great. If not then a tragedy will occure that is in no way Starfleet's fault or responsibility.

I could imagine that during the Dominion War a Humanitarian evacuation would have been out of the question.

BillJ wrote: View Post
Which simply isn't practical. Your level of help also depends on how practical that help is. It simply isn't practical to move a planetary population.
This. It unlikely that a entire planetary population in the tens of millions (or more) are going to be moved. Starfleet is simply going to have to employ some kind of selection process. to the majority of the population left behind (abandoned) on the doomed planet the selection process wouldn't be seen as fair. The people moved will have to be people who can re-establish their culture on a new planets, while at the same time being able to feed themselves after a short period of time.

Unless we want them to become dependent on Starfleet's on going assistance.

Last edited by T'Girl; July 7 2013 at 10:49 PM.
T'Girl is online now   Reply With Quote