View Single Post
Old June 30 2013, 08:24 PM   #581
Vice Admiral
T'Girl's Avatar
Re: Roddenberry's Worst Ideas

yousirname wrote: View Post
I don't care if there's never been a moneyless state. There's never been a space vessel with FTL drive, either.
But one is a transportation system, really just a form of propulsion. People in the 24th century might go their entire lives without ever setting foot on one.

The other is a major factor in every person's life. More than a economic system, it's would be one of the corner stones in the society and of the multi-culture that makes up their civilization.

nightwind1 wrote: View Post
Bad thoughts wrote: View Post
Ancient Egypt: transactions were conducted via measured amounts of grain, which could be used by the worker who earned it as food or for further transactions.
That's a lot more like "money" than barter.
Money and currency are not the same things, currency is money, but money isn't automatically currency.

Today, a single troy ounce of gold dust will buy you 260 bushels of corn (about seven and a quarter tonnes). That gold dust is money, solely because people will accept it.

Money is any object or record of accounting that is generally accepted as payment.

5000 years ago, in the middle east, a shekel of grain was money, it was a standardize amount of a substance (an object) that was generally accepted as payment.

Charles Phipps wrote: View Post
Either you believe people would do productive labor because of social pressure as well as a desire to contribute to society or you don't.
There another (or more) piece to that, beyond having a culture where people basically work for free, you have to have a culture that never changes away from working for free, not in decades, not in centuries. A mono-culture of volunteerism.

Which is almost an impossibility in a modern society for a protracted period of time. Humans will be in contact with hundreds of alien species, with many thousands of different cultures, lifestyles and ways of doing things.

Once the culture that changed to volunteerism, later changes then to "something" else, the world wide society that depended on volunteerism to operate either collapses or it adapts.

Can we move on?
I'm going to stick around for a while.

T'Girl is offline   Reply With Quote