Charles Phipps wrote:
Yeah, I suppose it's all down to Doylist (I.e this is a story written by authors) vs. Watsonian (this "happened" and everything should be made to fit) interpretations.
I mean, Trials and Tribulation is HILARIOUS but should, "We do not speak of it" have really become a story?
(They did well with that but I think people took it overboard)
True story: I once visited a mall bookstore that had a Sherlock Holmes novel filed under "W" for Watson . . ..