Will it be looked upon favourably in 10 years? I don't know.
BUT - There is another film that rehashed the Wrath of Khan that came out 11 years ago. How is that looked upon?
But wasn't that pretty much hated the day it opened?
Material that's re-used under different circumstances smacks of laziness, but I should know better than expect anything more sophisticated from a blowhard like Abrams, who hasn't told a worthwhile story since Alias ended.
I wonder how much of the venom that is pointed at Abrams is done so simply because he's successful at what he does. The Nolan Batman
films do nothing for me, but I don't run around trying to shit on them or him every chance I get. Same with Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
and Star Trek: Voyager
. I've simply got better things to do with my time.