50 years of implausible science, The Enterprise falls to earth, and THAT'S where you're drawing your 'Physics Line in the Sand'?
What, at the rules of gravity? Sure, why not.
has never obeyed the rules of gravity, since the ridiculously rapidly decaying orbits of TOS. Your insistence that it start obeying real orbital mechanics now, something it never, ever did before, is completely arbitrary.
So, to be clear, JJTrek is bad, because it isn't like old Trek
. And, it's bad, because it is
like old Trek
. It can never win.