Oh I could probably dispute some of that
The show wasn't a total disaster. It did some things very well...it just never reached it's full potential. It needed someone like Q to do that...or a different network, and a little more freedom. Q has been handcuffed with just one thing so far, but look at everything he's been able to accomplish so far? We're technically not even a third into the overall season either! This would probably be gutted quite a bit if was an actual television season.