I think efforts like these, while neat, only magnify the fact that Roddenberry and Company caught some very special lightning in the bottle nearly fifty years ago.
Pilgrims of Eternity
was entertaining but suffers from many of the same flaws other TOS fan films: they use sixties sets and sixties uniforms but the stories just don't match the setting.
What exactly was the point of the Counselor? Beautiful actress though. Gene would've approved.
Why didn't the crispy-fried redshirt point his phaser away from the hull?
The roles the women played here made the Abrams films look downright progressive.
So, does a plague wipe out Apollo's little world at some point and then he holds Kirk responsible for not checking up on them? The Wrath of Apollo
Spock reminds me of Sheldon from The Big Bang Theory
. That's not a good thing.
The actor playing Kirk needs to remember he's playing Kirk not William Shatner.