View Single Post
Old June 8 2013, 10:18 PM   #46
Nerys Myk
Fleet Admiral
Nerys Myk's Avatar
Location: Spock of Ages
Re: The Black Hole Remake

JarodRussell wrote: View Post
Christopher wrote: View Post
^Well, The Ten Commandments was a remake too. DeMille originally made it as a silent film in 1923, then remade and expanded it in '56, with many scenes recreated shot-for-shot.
Christopher wrote:
It's generally safe to assume that any '30s through '50s movie based on a classic or public-domain literary work was previously adapted as a silent film at least once. The bromide you keep hearing is that Hollywood "these days" has run out of ideas and is obsessed with remakes, but in fact, remakes were far more common and frequent in the early decades of cinema than they are today. After all, films often didn't get distributed as widely, and they didn't reappear on TV or home video, so one film version of a story might only reach a limited audience and then disappear, leaving the field wide open for another version.
That's why those examples for remakes don't count in my opinion. Charlton Heston Ten Commandments or Ben Hur, for example, is the first modern film version. Silent film is a whole different medium, like a stage play, or a book. And has there been remakes of 1950s Ten Commandments or Ben Hur that come remotely close to the quality of those "originals"?
Scenes remade shot for shot and yet they're different mediums?
Nerys Myk is offline   Reply With Quote