Enterprise would be smashed up again.
Not just smashed, the Enterprise blows up in Star Trek III
TMP: Enterprise unscathed.
TWOK: heavily damaged.
TVH: (only a cameo at the end).
TTF: no damage.
TUC: heavily damaged.
GEN: Enterprise destroyed.
FC: quite a bit of internal redecoration.
INS: no damage.
NEM: heavily damaged.
Nine movies with an Enterprise before ST09 and STID. Two are destroyed; three take a lot of battle damage; one is significantly damaged internally the Borg. Being on an Enterprise in the movies is like taking a chance on a Carnival cruise ship, for crying out loud.