Allyn Gibson wrote:
What's also problematic is this. Shouldn't the eleventh Doctor remember this moment from the perspective of the Hurt Doctor? However, the eleventh Doctor seemed genuinely surprised that his Hurt incarnation was there.
We have the same problem with "The Three," "Five," and "Two Doctors." They never even mentioned the issue in any of those. The only time we've ever seen a later Doctor remember having lived through a multi-Doctor meeting before was in "Time Crash." Though that was by Moffat too.